4 ms·
> This is a core argument that keeps getting spouted, and it's irrational nonsense. Because apparently recently "words are violence" and now we even hear "sile
by ekianjo 6y ago
> This is a core argument that keeps getting spouted, and it's irrational nonsense.
Because apparently recently "words are violence" and now we even hear "silence is violence".
This is so 1789 French Revolution style.
- cpursley 6y agoThe is more Cultural Revolution than French Revolution. Either way, it's a dangerous development that poses serious risk to free societies.
- d_e_solomon 6y agoYes, massive starvation and death due to inept industrial policies is the same as getting fired from your job for advocating hate speech. Next you'll tell me I'm literally hitler.
- cpursley 6y agoI don't think you understand what the Cultural Revolution was: "His students beat him to death during the Cultural Revolution. The school called it a suicide: https://www.latimes.com/world/asia/la-fg-china-cultural-revolution-suicides-snap-story.html https://www.latimes.com/world/asia/la-fg-china-cultural-revo... See any similarities?
- d_e_solomon 6y agoCan you see how firing somebody because they use hate speech isn't the same thing as killing someone because they are a Russian language professor?
- banads 6y agoCan you see how the former is a link in the same "chain of destruction"[1] as the latter? [1]https://youtu.be/c8N0TDsjpkE https://youtu.be/c8N0TDsjpkE You may be disinclined to watch this short video, but perhaps you would be surprised to see that it actually gives strong credence to the problems which you are seemingly arguing against, and which I too care deeply about.
- cpursley 6y ago> "take their jobs away and make it harder for them to survive" This bit from that clip was especially poignant, thanks for sharing.
- d_e_solomon 6y agoI'm fighting against speech that dehumanizes Jews, LGBT, Blacks, and so on; and ensuring that people who engage in it face consequences for that speech. This gets back to Hannah Arendt's paradox of tolerance.
- cpursley 6y agoSo in order to fight intolerance you're being intolerant. Got it. Fight fire with fire.
- d_e_solomon 6y agoAt what point am I allowed to fight back? If someone advocates exterminating me, do I have your permission to suggest that their speech should have consequences? Or do I have to wait until I'm dead?
- cpursley 6y agoDo you believe that most people getting "mob cancelled" right now are overtly advocating extermination? If so, can you provide a few examples so I can better understand your position?
- slowmovintarget 6y agoFirst, it is Karl Popper's "paradox of tolerance". The conclusion his argument leads to is: In a tolerant society, attacking people because of their beliefs is not permitted (requisite intolerance). You don't fight against speech, you speak against its ideas.
- banads 6y agoWhy do you focus so narrowly on "fighting" speech, rather than the ongoing actions that are dehumanizing humans of all types?
- neonate 6y agoGetting someone fired causes them real harm. It's not at all out of the question that this harm could escalate to the point of imprisoning people or even killing them. The motive seems pretty similar to me. Don't forget that the ideologically motivated killings and imprisonments of the past were all justified using the same sort of arguments that you're making here, and the pattern of public denunciation is unmistakably similar. The arguments you've been making in this thread ("Speech that oppresses minorities deny their fundamental right to exist. Wouldn't you fight back if someone wanted to take away your life?") could justify action way beyond firing. If these arguments are valid, what wouldn't you have the right to do? If the harms being caused to date are "only" limited to firing, that's not because the denouncers are restraining themselves. It's because the protections of liberal society prevent them from doing worse. It's easy to imagine those protections getting diluted further, and easy to imagine worse harms than firing getting inflicted on people as a result. So I don't think this "what do they have to complain about" response is really valid.
- ekianjo 6y agoI think you miss the part why it was called "Cultural" revolution.
- d_e_solomon 6y agoYes. Because losing your job due to using hate speech is the same as losing your head for being on the wrong side of the committee of public safety. Next you'll tell me that I'm literally hitler.
- ekianjo 6y ago> Next you'll tell me that I'm literally hitler. You seem to be repeating yourself. > the same as losing your head for being on the wrong side of the committee of public safety. Your pattern recognition engine must have some problems. In 1789 and the following years people were vilified and arrested (and eventually killed by truckloads, but that's not the point) because they were too moderate or not extreme enough compared to the radicals leading the "new culture". Here's what St just said in the good old 90's (1790s): > "We must not only punish traitors, but all people who are not enthusiastic. There are only two kinds of citizens: the good and the bad. The Republic owes to the good its protection. To the bad it owes only death." And Robespierre: > "There are only two parties in France: the people and its enemies. We must exterminate those miserable villains who are eternally conspiring against the rights of man... We must exterminate all our enemies.” " If you don't see any parallel with what's happening right now (the insidious dichotomy between good and bad), minus the guillotine, I am not sure what else I can tell you.
- d_e_solomon 6y agoYour argument is that state sponsored violence for incorrect political opinions is the same as being fired by a private corporation for hate speech. Those aren't equivalent and one doesn't lead to the other.
- ryandrake 6y agoThe "silence is violence" stuff is particularly troubling because it eliminates indifference as a choice for people who simply don't have an opinion about whatever the issue is, and fosters a false with-us-or-against-us dichotomy. I honestly don't care about most of the political dramas of the day, but by not caring, I'm now somehow guilty of supporting the status quo! This is bonkers.