11 ms·
We are all prisoners of groupthink
- tech_timc 6y agoI've been thinking that, too. . .
- throw_this_one 6y agoGroupthink is huge now because of the online echo-chambers that people can very easily surround themselves with. Look on Instagram with the BLM stuff. There are tons of radical accounts that just post whatever in a cool infographic, and then it gets shared on peoples stories. And it's actually pretty anti-white and racist itself.
- nickthegreek 6y agoexamples?
- throw_this_one 6y agoBasically start at Shaun King and then go from there. He's HUGE with that crowd and his posts are very questionable. At the minimum, the undertone is palpable for every post.
- jariel 6y ago? Not hard to come across. Here is a BLM supporting moniker: "BLMACAB white people are a disease" [1] Literally that's their title/moniker, it's not even a Tweet, it's in every Tweet! Now if that's not racist, then what is? And how does Twitter not consider that 'hate speech'? How has this not been flagged? And how are advertisers not concerned about such language on Twitter, but they are of Facebook? Obviously, it's not the same thing as racism 'in the other direction' due to issues of power etc. but it's still racist. This is common in Twitter. I watched the 'Prisoner' series as a kid on re-runs, it's absolutely amazing. I'll never forget it, it's like nothing else. That said, I do think the author of the piece is a tiny bit one-sided on it, I don't think it's about the kind of progressive-groupthink, I think it's pointed a little bit more broadly. Many classical, orthodox societies obviously have degrees of pushing social conformity etc.. [1] https://twitter.com/aikawasfatpussy https://twitter.com/aikawasfatpussy
- corporateslave5 6y agoThe front page of reddit is straight up anti white
- throw_this_one 6y agoLol it's hilarious and also sad. Hey the cabal or whatever achieved their goal of making it trendy to be anti-white. Using anecdotal evidence or misleading statistics (most readers can't properly understand statistics anyway)
- JoeSmithson 6y agoWhat is the highest post on /r/all at the moment that you consider anti-white?
- dEnigma 6y agoThis struck me as a ridiculous statement, so I just checked the front page and not a single thing I saw could be classified as anti-white by any reasonable standard.
- pstuart 6y agoHow do you know those radical accounts aren't intentionally so, to discredit the movement? Equating the BLM movement with groupthink is actually groupthink.
- throw_this_one 6y agoStart with Shaun King, who is followed by millions. You can easily see the undertones on most of his posts.
- pstuart 6y agoWikipedia has this: In June 2020, King tweeted that statues, murals, and stained glass windows depicting a white Jesus should be removed. "Yes, I think the statues of the white European they claim is Jesus should also come down," he tweeted. "They are a form of white supremacy. Always have been. Are you hurt by that assertion? Please show citations where actual "anti-white" comments are made. N.B. calling white people out on their shit is not "anti-white".
- jariel 6y agoThis is driving the problem if you're literally quoting blatantly 'anti-white' statements and then wondering where the 'anti-white' sentiment is. This language is certainly within the threshold of civility, he should be able to say such things without being 'cancelled' , but it's obviously 'anti white' and casually racist. He's antagonising to make a name for himself. This is the equivalent of Trump's 'Whuan Virus' rhetoric.
- pstuart 6y agoIt's not "anti-white". It's calling out a lie. If Jesus was real (and I'm in the camp that believes he wasn't), he wasn't white. I'm as white as they come and these statements don't threaten me. How was the statement I cited racist?
- 6y ago
- psquared2 6y agoI think the biggest take-away from "cancel culture is bad" letters and articles is that they never come with specific examples. For example, Gareth Roberts says he was cancelled but never say why https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Gareth_Roberts_(writer)#Transgender_controversy https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Gareth_Roberts_(writer)#Transg... He said transgenderism is "It's almost like a clueless gayboy's idea of a glamorous lady." It's ok to have an opinion, but if you insist it beyond being respectful and/or scientific evidences, you deserve a backlash. It's almost as if actions have consequences.
- Vomzor 6y agoHere's a list of examples: https://twitter.com/SpeechUnion/status/1269314030663012352 https://twitter.com/SpeechUnion/status/1269314030663012352
- jchook 6y agoImagine using your career position as a platform to argue that Black Americans should use “separate but equal” facilities in 2020. Should you get fired? Or is that free speech?
- ekianjo 6y agoThat's what the ACLU has been screaming on the rooftops for years: "We All Need to Defend Speech We Hate" https://www.aclu.org/blog/free-speech/we-all-need-defend-speech-we-hate https://www.aclu.org/blog/free-speech/we-all-need-defend-spe...
- asdf21 6y ago>Imagine using your career position as a platform to argue that Black Americans should use “separate but equal” facilities in 2020. Isn't that one of the core tenants of the BLM campaigns? "Separate but equal" community policing for African American neighborhoods..
- deleted 6y ago[deleted]
- spinach 6y agoIt only became obvious to me when I found out about the transgender debate, and that you aren't allowed to discuss reality. Just repeat 'transwomen are women' and anything against that is hate speech. You can't acknowledge they are male. It's insane. So many people are banned from twitter just for saying men can't be women, youtube channels are demontized, and the big Gender Critical sub on reddit was recently banned, for 'hate speech'. Simply because they don't believe transwomen are women. It's identity politics and this push of feelings and individual's 'truth' over actual reality and data. I've never felt so terrified. You can't talk about reality, about a lot of things. The BLM movement is the same. If the actual facts don't fit the narrative, you can't say them. How can we fix the problems if we can't even acknowledge what is real?
- ptd 6y agoTrans people are killing themselves at alarming rates along with a slew of other issues. Why is your ability to disagree with them more important than their lives?
- ximeng 6y agoThose shouldn’t be in opposition to each other, surely.
- andrewclunn 6y agoMost youth grow out of sexual dismorphia. Tgose that don't have an increased suicide rate. So promoting transitioning in adolescence increases suicide. I mean not that I need to make an argument from final consequences to justify free speech, but since you did, might as well point out that it's crap.
- war1025 6y agoAnd ten years ago the answer to that would have been: "Identifying as a gender you aren't is a mental health issue. And mental health issues often lead to suicide and other bad outcomes." No matter how you feel about transgender issues, there is no denying that they currently have an outsized influence on the media narrative.
- 6y ago
- d_e_solomon 6y agoSpeech has consequences. If you make statements that are blatantly: - Racist - Anti LGBT - Anti Trans - Misogynistic Then don't be surprised when other people call you out on it and you face consequences. We're not discussing some random philosophical pie in the sky question. Speech that oppresses minorities deny their fundamental right to exist. Wouldn't you fight back if someone wanted to take away your life?
- travisoneill1 6y agoPlease give an example of speech taking someone's life.
- haswell 6y agohttps://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Death_of_Conrad_Roy https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Death_of_Conrad_Roy
- d_e_solomon 6y agohttps://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Matthew_Shepard https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Matthew_Shepard
- gerbal 6y agoHate crimes spring to mind. People tell lies about minority groups, give themselves permission structures to justify violence, and vigilantes take it upon themselves to "fix" the problem with violence. A lot of people have been murdered on as a result of hate speech. Emit Till, Michael Donald, James Byrd are a few. Also, the Rwandan Genocide, historical Pogroms, lynchings, arguably the holocaust. It's pretty hard to get humans to murder their neightbors without inciting speech.
- luckylion 6y ago> It's pretty hard to get humans to murder their neightbors without inciting speech. Eh, I'm not so sure about that. En masse, with coordination? Maybe, but speech is mostly about coordination at that stage. Would you say that everybody ever saying something untruthful or hatefull about the GOP is responsible for some lunatic storming the base ball practice of some GOP members of Congress with a gun and shooting at them? Speech is certainly involved in the actual act of a pogrom, but it's not the driving force (unless your definition of speech gets really vague and everything ever said since the beginning of time is part of "the speech"). You don't have pogroms without previous animosity. Somebody saying something might spark the fire, but the wood has been there all along, soaked in gasoline.
- chadcmulligan 6y agoProbably off topic but Patrick McGoohan was in a couple of good series for those at home at the moment, apart from The Prisoner, Danger Man was another (A bond like spy), and he also turns up in a few episodes of Columbo. If you like those then try the Avengers - the one with Patrick McNee and Emma peel, there are other series but the Emma Peel one is recognised as the best. Surrealist Spy dramas were at their height in that era, if you want to go further 'The Champions' is another - three spies crash land in Tibet and monks teach them some powers.
- deleted 6y ago[deleted]
- jfengel 6y agoIt's kinda remarkable to watch people respond to "All people groupthink" with "Yeah, all those other people out there groupthink".
- TiredGuy 6y agoThat was also illustrated well in an xkcd comic: https://xkcd.com/610/ https://xkcd.com/610/ Seems like human tendency to want to feel unique.
- oehpr 6y agoThis comment is getting at a frustration I have with this article. I've come to learn about area's where I'm unintentionally falling into the patterns of thinking of those around me without due consideration. But the article is ultimately a "This is where the tolerant left is taking us". With the US elections going on, I am desperately sick of this rhetoric.
- dwaltrip 6y agoIt stands to reason that some people, for whatever reason, are somewhat less susceptible. It would be a strange world indeed if the susceptibility was exactly the same across all humans. Many questions quickly surface, though. How can we tell who is less susceptible? How can we mode this variance? A single fixed number from 1 to 100 is certainly insufficient. And even if we can start to understand these phenomena, under what conditions can we actually apply the new knowledge for widespread benefit? What are the risks?
- Numberwang 6y agohe fucked one of them. it was not the same.
- hogFeast 6y agoI think a lot of people here have missed the point. Social media has made it far easier to display your values to other people. Rather than led to diversity, it has massively consolidated the range of "acceptable" opinions to a serious of slogans and "approved" ideas that everyone must agree with. And btw, I don't think actual values have changed. But what has happened is that we have a very vocal and determined minority that feels the need to judge other people who disagree with them. That is the point of the Village. Everything you do is controlled by social pressure. To give an example, where I am the police now spend a lot of time on social media prosecuting because it is so easy to build a case. Social media is the avenue for this control. Just personally, I was never the biggest fan of social media. I thought Facebook was a conspiracy to steal my personal data in 2008. But I did use Twitter to build a business a few years later. I would never do this again. You are just exposed to far too many idiots. This was true back in 2011 when I was using it, it is doubly true today. Social media encourages idiots to have an opinion about things they don't understand.
- deleted 6y ago[deleted]
- commandlinefan 6y agoI'm old enough to remember the Christian conservative mob of the 80's - the Jerry Falwell/Pat Buchanan/Tipper Gore crowd. When they went after you, they were vicious. They were ruthless. They wouldn't stop until they had done everything they could to destroy you. Slowly, people started waking up to the damage they were causing - in particular, sexual deviants (like homosexuals) were at the top of their hit list. Rational people started pushing back. Although it seemed unimaginable in the mid-80's, by the mid-90's, they had been made irrelevant by constant, gentle backpressure. Now, though, the people that they targeted, instead of rejoicing that their oppressors are finally powerless to harm them, are taking up the mantle of oppressor themselves. There's a sense of "giving them a taste of their own medicine" - and if the actual perpetrators are too hard to find, anybody that reminds them of the perpetrators will do. History suggests that this, too, will ultimately be defeated, but not after a lot of damage is done to very innocent bystanders.
- banads 6y agoThere is a comical irony to how those roles have flip flopped over these recent decades. Evidence of how we humans do in fact have so much more in common than we give ourselves credit for -- all the while these groups hyper focus only on our differences.
- at_a_remove 6y agoI am in the same boat as you. For me, I didn't dislike the people -- I pried myself away from that habit -- and grew to dislike the tactics. Seeing them taken up by the formerly oppressed is very disheartening. That jackboot that has been stomping my face in, I wonder if it fits me?
- banads 6y ago>That jackboot that has been stomping my face in, I wonder if it fits me? "If only there were evil people somewhere insidiously committing evil deeds, and it were necessary only to separate them from the rest of us and destroy them. But the line dividing good and evil cuts through the heart of every human being. And who is willing to destroy a piece of his own heart? During the life of any heart this line keeps changing place; sometimes it is squeezed one way by exuberant evil and sometimes it shifts to allow enough space for good to flourish. One and the same human being is, at various ages, under various circumstances, a totally different human being. At times he is close to being a devil, at times to sainthood. But his name doesn't change, and to that name we ascribe the whole lot, good and evil. Socrates taught us: "Know thyself." Confronted by the pit into which we are about to toss those who have done us harm, we halt, stricken dumb: it is after all only because of the way things worked out that they were the executioners and we weren't. From good to evil is one quaver, says the proverb. And correspondingly, from evil to good." -Gulag Archipeligo
- disposekinetics 6y agoThis is a good mantra, along with "You are not immune to propaganda"
- diffrinse 6y agoFascinating myth that we all keep telling each other and ourselves that we fully own all our desires and behaviors. Western secular life continues to betray itself as a species of Christianity. European antiquity had no notion of this kind of counter-social autonomy (and no, that's not what Stoicism is about, much as people are mining it for the same gold they were trying to get out of Buddhism and Taosim in the 80s/90s). Then you read through Levi-Straussian anthropology and realize its probably the case most, if not all, cultures on Earth don't sport this peculiarity. So many moral/ethical concepts in the West, and American culture in particular as it seemingly double-downs on most sof it, are just straight up blind alleys.
- leereeves 6y agoIn what way is the "counter-social autonomy" that led to religious freedom, democracy, and the end of slavery a blind alley? The social structures of antiquity (European or otherwise) were horrible. We should be grateful to the people who had the courage to defy those social norms.