3 ms·
The Balkan mentality, greatly twisted in the half millennium of Ottoman rule, does not help much either. I don't think this sort of ethnic essentialism is at a
by pvg 6y ago
The Balkan mentality, greatly twisted in the half millennium of Ottoman rule, does not help much either.
I don't think this sort of ethnic essentialism is at all necessary to explain Bulgaria's current problems. It seems especially misplaced given Bulgarian Turks and muslims were subjected to ethnic cleansing quite recently, in the decade before the horrors in neighbouring Yugoslavia.
Petko Slaveykov's famous line 'не сме народ, а мърша' was written in 1875. The fact that it's becoming more literally true than he meant it is hardly the fault of the Ottoman Empire.
- mattjaynes 6y agoFor those who don't speak Bulgarian (like me), google translate of "не сме народ, а мърша" is "we are not a people, but a carcass". Though I'm sure a native speaker would probably have a better translation.
- pvg 6y agoIt's good enough for government work! I didn't translate it because it can come off as far too inflammatory - it happens to be a line from a well-known poem by one of the founders of modern Bulgarian written literature.
- Veen 6y agoThat attitude is quite common in Eastern and central Europe. When I, as a Brit, lived in Hungary I often heard Hungarians apologising for the “Hungarian mentality” or “hungarian thinking” when something went wrong or appeared ill-conceived.
- pvg 6y agoAbsolutely. Here's a Bulgarian example https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Bay_Ganyo https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Bay_Ganyo But despite getting the works 500 years ago, it's more than a little silly to blame it on the Turks.
- acqq 6y ago> it's more than a little silly to blame it on the Turks. Not somebody who would be ready to unconditionally defend Bulgarians, but here I don't agree at all. The "Turks" weren't there "500 years ago" they were there for more than 500 years and were there even 200 years ago, and during these centuries all the "non-Turks" lived in the constant very strong discrimination, across the huge empire that included a big part of Mediterranean: https://cdn.britannica.com/89/4789-050-B6176F52/Expansion-Ottoman-Empire.jpg https://cdn.britannica.com/89/4789-050-B6176F52/Expansion-Ot... It's not an excuse but a fact. I know it's today fashionable to ignore centuries lasting discrimination of huge swaths of population, but it's wrong.
- pvg 6y agothey were there for more than 500 years I think that qualifies you for not a 'they'. That's an 'us'.
- acqq 6y ago> not a 'they' I dully confirm, I'm definitely not an apologetic of Ottoman empire. One of the greatest things that happened to the 20th century was the abolition of Caliphate, March 1924. That allowed huge changes in the minds of people in some former parts of it: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=jzBVCcpn_iY https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=jzBVCcpn_iY Last decades we observe immense attempts for these changes to be undone, and they are more successful that most would like to admit. It's not about any ethnicity, it's about the politics and the system based on the oppression.
- pvg 6y agoI guess I don't understand how a video of Nasser is supposed to convince me Bulgarian ethnic and religious minorities are any less Bulgarian than they are.
- acqq 6y ago> Bulgarian ethnic and religious minorities Note that I never talked about "Bulgarian ethnic and religious minorities". My perspective was much broader. If you ever believed I'm part of these specific minorities, I can assure you I'm not. If you happen to be a member of these, and you don't agree with my perspective, it's also understandable, I admit however that I've missed that this "they" and "us" could also be interpreted in that way. My "us" was in the sense "us who don't hide the historical facts when they are not favorable to some." But that could give a hint why it was important for you to disclaim the blame. Current minorities of course can't be blamed for the period when the oppressors identified themselves with the same name. > less Bulgarian than they are Where did you get that idea that somebody here wrote something like that?
- deleted 6y ago[deleted]