6 ms·
This may be the first interesting/good use for the Touch Bar many HN'ers have seen. But the touchbar was designed primarily for AV professionals from the begin
by crazygringo 6y ago
This may be the first interesting/good use for the Touch Bar many HN'ers have seen.
But the touchbar was designed primarily for AV professionals from the beginning -- sliding controls for filmstrips, audio sliders, colors, etc.
It's just that most developers have never needed to do any work like that, and have never used the creative apps that expose this, so don't see the point.
But it's genuinely for the "professional" part of Pro. Not develop professionals, but creative professionals.
- WWLink 6y agoA programmer is a creative professional. But now I'm just splitting hairs lol. I get your point but I'm annoyed at the "real professionals" bit there. :)
- randomdata 6y ago> This may be the first interesting/good use for the Touch Bar many HN'ers have seen. I've only recently started using a device with the TouchBar, but as a developer I've really enjoyed having debugging controls on it. It is nice being able to have the main screen focused on the running application and having the secondary debugging tools on the TouchBar.
- breatheoften 6y agodebugging imo is terrible via the touchbar -- but was also terrible with function keys! Binding a two character keystroke (cmd-shift-c for step next for me) is vastly superior ux than a function key or touchbar provide ... i think the location of the touchbar above the useable space in the keyboard is a huge issue with it -- it's just not a useable space. it was hard to use function keys as well for this reason. the touchbar would be kind of interesting for the creative uses i think if it was a separate physical device that you could put where you want it. a thing with a magnet maybe that you can attach to the bottom of the keyboard beneath the touchpad ... it's there when you are in an editing mentality and wanting to use those sliders -- relax and leave your fingers down close to you rather than raised and prone and stretching ...
- misnome 6y agoHow do you mean? More than the usual start stop step-in step-over? With physical keys you can “home” your finger and press without drifting or looking down at the bar, and I find that much easier. About the only thing I’ve found useful is when plugging in a projector and getting the “mirror or extend” buttons directly rather than having to remember which symbol it is. Every other case it’s felt inferior and gotten in the way (like display/sound/volume access in an app that uses it)
- saagarjha 6y agoI've found it really useful to be able to stop an app without doing anything that would require it loosing focus. Without this I need to do run something like sleep 10; kill -STOP `pgrep app` in the terminal and then scramble to get the app in the state I want.
- forgotmypw17 6y agoDo you know about Cmd+Alt+Esc?
- saagarjha 6y agoI mean, I know that you can force quit apps from it…
- rswail 6y agoNo but thank you, I do know :) I know UXs are supposed to be discoverable these days, but FFS, do I just press random combinations of meta keys to find out what they do?
- jeffhuys 6y agoIf you click on the apple logo top-left, you'll see "Force quit apps" with the relevant shortcut next to it.
- pcr910303 6y ago> With physical keys you can “home” your finger and press without drifting or looking down at the bar, and I find that much easier. You can also develop muscle memory with the Touch Bar as I've mentioned in my comment: https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=23786774 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=23786774
- bsdubernerd 6y agoThe parent's post is spot on IMHO. The analog possibilities of the touchbar can really help in doing creative work, and I never thought of it this way. But it's still overblown though, since the same interface is available on the xxl touchpad and would be better served with a gesture (so that aiming a narrow spot is not necessary). As a dev I would never replace regular function keys. You certainly didn't lack shortcuts for debugging without a touchbar. But I definitely see the point it being an accessibility feature (in that case though, my thought goes to something like this https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Optimus_Maximus_keyboard https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Optimus_Maximus_keyboard instead)
- pishpash 6y agoLack of tactile feedback and fat finger issues (even while typing) make this unlikely to be true.
- crazygringo 6y agoWell, regardless of how unlikely you think it is... it's still true. You don't need tactile feedback when the feedback is real-time in the image on the monitor or the sound in your headphones. It's audiovisual feedback in the actual creative product you're creating. And the touch bar is definitely tall enough to handle the fattest fingers. ;) Not sure why you bring typing into it.
- recursivecaveat 6y agoI constantly fat-finger it while typing in numbers. Bad enough that I just removed all the application-specific controls. No big deal if I accidentally adjust the brightness one notch, but accidentally tapping Quit was obnoxious.
- userbinator 6y agoYou don't need tactile feedback when the feedback is real-time in the image on the monitor or the sound in your headphones. It's not as "real-time" as the feedback from the key itself. There are physical keyboards without tactile feedback, but studies have shown that most people will drastically slow down when typing on one.
- deleted 6y ago[deleted]
- xzel 6y agoI agree I think is a good intended set of use cases but I don't think only a single bar was a good idea at all. If I was doing stuff like Ableton or an Adobe product with sliders, I'd want an iPad sized group of sliders, knobs and other settings. I've found my only real use case is using Poc and launching apps. I find the text auto correct / smilie suggestion useless and borderline distracting and annoying while I'm trying to type (too much flashing).
- whywhywhywhy 6y agoIf they developed an actual touch screen laptop you wouldn't need it though. I fully expect it to be removed from the upcoming touchscreen ARM MBP.
- chrismorgan 6y agoHave you any reason to expect a touchscreen ARM MacBook Pro? I have heard of no credible rumours to that effect (though I don’t follow the space). I know a few people misinterpreted something from WWDC (can’t remember what) to think it meant touchscreen Macs were coming, but that was definitely a misconstruction.
- whywhywhywhy 6y agoThe Big Sur UI being more spaced out hints at it. The fact it runs iOS apps unmodified only really works flawlessly if the user can touch the screen otherwise there will be some multitouch functionality only phone users can use and would require devs to put in extra work. Most of the rumor mill close to Apple (John Gruber, atp.fm etc) all believe it's coming. The devices (iPad/MBP) are clearly starting to converge and I think the next MBP is going to be genetically closer to an iPad than it is todays MBP, you can tell they've been leaving a ton of enhancements out of the current lineup waiting for an evolution, MBP lags behind all other premium laptops in webcam quality, LTE, touch support, pen support and screen bezel and the ARM transition is definitely the time to push this evolutionary update.
- chrismorgan 6y agoUI spacing: I’m not at all convinced. iOS apps: but consider how Apple added (is adding? I don’t use the ecosystem) a pointer to iPadOS. That’s heading towards apps not requiring touch for interactions. Webcam quality: I dunno, most expensive laptops I’ve seen also have lousy 720p webcams. (I have a Surface Book, which is more like a tablet in this regard, having both a front- and a rear-facing camera, both fairly decent. LTE: not particularly common in laptops. It’s always been niche functionality. It has always seemed weird to me how much of a schism there has been between tablets and laptops in things like cameras and LTE. (Microsoft are the ones that started tearing down the dividing wall of partition in the Surface line of products; but it’s still mostly intact.) I’ll be interested to see what comes of it (though have no plans to ever acquire any Apple gear).
- PostThisTooFast 6y ago"But it's genuinely for the "professional" part of Pro. Not develop professionals, but creative professionals." Wrong. I am both a developer, and a developer of image-processing and video-editing software. I will never waste a minute of development time supporting this useless piece of shit. Why would I? It's not even reliably available on Apple computers, let alone on a cross-platform basis. And nobody with junior-high-or-better typing skill is LOOKING at his keyboard. This entire gimmick is so poorly conceived that it stands as a testament to Apple's ignorance of what real-world users want in a computer. But then, so did five years of the disgracefully defective keyboards on every one of Apple's laptops. Jony Ive was a pompous hack, and Apple has not wiped his pathetic legacy away with enough vigor to redeem its product line.