4 ms·
Chinese universities do have this concept -- certain students are marked VIP, so that professors will know. But the concept of granting admission based on such
by thaumasiotes 6y ago
Chinese universities do have this concept -- certain students are marked VIP, so that professors will know.
But the concept of granting admission based on such status, as opposed to extending special treatment to an admitted student, is very much muted.
There are ways of getting in to a university without passing the gaokao threshold that would ordinarily be required. But those generally involve receiving a point boost that the college has the official discretion to offer, or doing well on an alternative test -- someone scoring 303 out of 750 would obviously not pass a lower discretionary threshold either.
Note that when "officials in Shandong say new processes are now in place to make sure such incidents will not happen again", they are correct -- it's already possible to look up both your gaokao score (this girl's score wasn't falsified; rather, her identity was stolen) and the 分数线 that applied to you when you applied to a school. The problem would be instantly detected[1] by anyone who felt bitter about what happened -- and this is quite likely, since you have a strong idea of what your gaokao score will be before you actually take the test. (You have to, because you apply to colleges before you get your official result.)
[1] Well, detected with probably a one-year lag.
- thewarrior 6y agoChina as a civilization takes the notion of a merit based on examinations very seriously. They pioneered this system hundreds of years before anywhere else in the world. Cheating may exist but in terms of valuing meritocracy China has it as deeply ingrained as the west.
- east2west 6y agoOn paper, yes, China takes official examination rather seriously. In realty, a saying in China goes: as long as there are exams, there are cheaters. An ancient Chinese source estimates that 20% to 30% participants of imperial exams are imposters. Endless examples of high ranking officials pave way for their descendants to succeed as top performers. A renown prime minister invited the chief examiner to his library, where he had removed all reading materials except a copy of an essay his son would write for the upcoming exam. The chief examiner was left waiting forever, so he was forced to read the only reading material within reach. When he later read it again as part of national exam, he recognized it immediately and made the the son of the prime minister NO. 1. This only came out because the emperor did not want PM's family become too powerful, but merely demoted the son from NO. 1 to NO. 3. Not unlike elite institutions in the West, publicly the imperial exam system was lauded but a system of "donation" co-existed to fill official posts. This is a legal way to buy one's way into officialdom. "Legacy" entry was also available, not unlike today's system in China or elsewhere. Human nature prevails everywhere.
- deleted 6y ago[deleted]
- gowld 6y agoCheating is also deeply ingrained in the culture, though. Much like it is in the US entrepreneurial culture (not just VC backed companies and fortune 500s, but mom and pop businesses). Old history is one thing, but the whole country being run as a corporation for the past 70 years is another.
- Retric 6y agoOfficial VIP students... wow that’s horrifyingly corrupt. Clearly admissions is also letting things slide, just with less official backing as fewer people need to be involved. In the US, collages have more or less rigorous programs rather than simply letting people slide through.
- thaumasiotes 6y ago> Official VIP students... wow that’s horrifyingly corrupt. Clearly admissions is also letting things slide, just with less official backing. I do not think your conclusion follows from your premise.
- Retric 6y agoYou just said: “There are ways of getting in to a university without passing the gaokao threshold that would ordinarily be required.” VIP students is a way to communicate across the university. Otherwise professors have no way of knowing who they need to give extra leniency to. I know collage professors at several schools and we really have nothing widespread like that.
- Tostino 6y agoCollege* Not to be a jerk, I just saw you make the same spelling mistake a couple times
- deleted 6y ago[deleted]
- justicezyx 6y agoOfficial VIP usually include: * Minority race * Very poor areas * People with certain disability but not affecting learning capability The hidden official VIP: * Descents and relatives of people with power
- rland 6y agoYou'll be amazed when you find out about legacy admissions!
- gowld 6y agoThe OP is about middle class people stealing credentials, which creates a specific victim. Hiring people to take a test for you is another popular way to cheat the system, and there is no single victim who can complain.