5 ms·
I hate this line of reasoning and so do many economists. It’s not the “opportunity cost” you should be measuring. It’s the “opportunity cost of the next best a
by scarface74 6y ago
I hate this line of reasoning and so do many economists.
It’s not the “opportunity cost” you should be measuring. It’s the “opportunity cost of the next best alternative.”
If I am an hourly worker making $50 and going to get food would be an hour that I wouldn’t be working, then yes it is worth $50 to not spend it going to get food.
But if I am choosing between watching Netflix and going to get food. The next best alternative pays $0. From a purely financial view it makes sense to get food.
- s1artibartfast 6y agoMost simply, some people value their leisure time as much or more than their hourly wage. I find this become more true the more someone is compensated and the more they have to work.
- scarface74 6y agoI have no problem with that. Just don’t wrap it in some BS about opportunity cost and how much their time is worth. There are three concepts that HN commenters don’t understand - “Monopoly” and anti-trust - the legal concept of censorship. - opportunity costs.
- ByteJockey 6y agoI just want to make sure I'm following your train of thought correctly regarding this object. So, say, an hourly contractor who orders delivery so they can get back to work sooner still makes sense to you, right?
- scarface74 6y agoIf he would get more hours in during that time instead of going home earlier, then you could value the time saved against how much it would cost. If he makes $50 an hour and he can get an extra hour in working, if it is cheaper for him to order food then yes it makes economic sense. On the other hand if he were at home watching Netflix and he spent the money set aside for his utility bill to eat out and his lights got cut off , the opportunity cost wasn’t the $50, it was that he could have had lights.
- ByteJockey 6y agoAlright. Just wanted to make sure I was following your train of thought. Thanks for taking the time to elaborate. You have a good one.
- nybble41 6y ago> It’s not the “opportunity cost” you should be measuring. It’s the “opportunity cost of the next best alternative.” Opportunity cost is exactly that: the next best alternative. > But if I am choosing between watching Netflix and going to get food. The next best alternative pays $0. If you could be spending that time earning $50, and you choose to watch Netflix instead—all else being equal—then obviously watching Netflix is worth more to you than the $50. Going to get food thus implies foregoing at least $50 worth of leisure time. The fact that no one is paying you to watch Netflix is irrelevant; monetary compensation is not the sole (or even most signficant) measure of economic value.
- scarface74 6y agoI agree that monetary compensation is not the sole economic value. But still “how much you could be making that hour” is also irrelevant in most cases. That’s the entire point.
- cwilkes 6y agoNo it is highly relevant. I’m “making” happiness by watching a film on Netflix instead of getting dressed, getting in the car, struggling to find parking, waiting for the order, and then driving back. This is an economic decision just One that not easily seen by dollars. I value a movie more than running errands.
- scarface74 6y agoAnd that still doesn’t have anything to do with the original thesis - “if I make $50/hour when I am working. That means I should value my time at $50/hour”. The opportunity cost is not $50/hour if you wouldn’t have been using that hour to work.
- nybble41 6y ago> The opportunity cost is not $50/hour if you wouldn’t have been using that hour to work. It is at least $50 per hour if you could have been using that time to work. Anything else that you choose to do instead of working is prima facie worth more to you than the $50 you could have been earning. The opportunity cost—the next best alternative—is either working and earning $50 or else something you value even more than $50. You are attempting to claim the opposite: that if someone can make $50 per hour working, but chooses to do something else, then that time is somehow worth less than $50 per hour. This makes no sense at all. This would presume that the person knowingly and deliberately chooses the option which is less valuable from their own point of view.
- austhrow743 6y agoIt's not a decision you make every single time you order food. It's lifestyle. Put in just your 9-5 then bail or put extra time and effort in to your career. Many high earners in cities are doing the latter. You take the time you'd be using not only be getting your food but cleaning, mowing, looking after your car; all of the work that isn't your job, and use it to earn more instead. The higher you earn, the more this makes sense to do. Hours are interchangeable. Sure if you order food at 7:30, get it delivered at 8, and you spend 7:30-8 watching Netflix then yeah the next best alternative for that half an hour was $0. That's not where the trade off happened though. It's when you left work at 6 instead of 5. It's when you answer that phone call or email you otherwise wouldn't have later that night. It's going out for drinks the next day with that weird guy you shared an office with until he left a few weeks ago to work at a company you really want to move to.
- wittyreference 6y agoI don't understand why economists would hate it. The opportunity cost doesn't have to be dollars - it could be in universal "utility measure" units. If I value the utility measure of what I'm giving up to get food > than I value the utility measure of the cost of delivery, I don't want to give up that utility to go get food.
- scarface74 6y agoI am not saying that money is the end all be all. I am saying that the intellectually honest reason is that “I have the money to spend on doing things I don’t want to do myself”. Not, “Because I make $50/hour, for 8 hours a day, my time is worth $50 and every hour I get back in my life is worth $50/hour”.