3 ms·
Suppose you are importing a shipping container full of canned tomatoes. Due to negligence, it is improperly stacked on the deck of the container ship, and in ro
by skissane 6y ago
Suppose you are importing a shipping container full of canned tomatoes. Due to negligence, it is improperly stacked on the deck of the container ship, and in rough seas it slides off the deck and into the water. Luckily for you, you have insurance, and you submit a claim to your insurer. Does the insurer reimburse what you paid, wholesale, to buy that many cans of tomatoes? Or does the insurer calculate its value by multiplying the number of cans by the average retail sale price of a single can, and then pay you that? Obviously they do they first not the second. And, conversely, if you were uninsured, what loss do you book in your accounting? The first loss, not the second.
I think this example, which has nothing to do with illegal drugs, demonstrates the problem with how law enforcement calculates the value of seized illegal drugs (at least in their media releases).
- jacquesm 6y agoThe street value is the only value they could possibly quote with some accuracy, it is not as though Cocaine is a listed wholesale commodity. But I think if you discount by 50% or so you'll be pretty close which is still an immense amount of money for a single shipment. 14.5 Million TEU / year. How big a fraction of those are drug decoys?
- colechristensen 6y agoIf their detectives are worth their salt, they will know how the prices at port fluctuate.
- Udik 6y ago> But I think if you discount by 50% or so you'll be pretty close Look, a metric ton of sugar wholesale costs about $250. When you buy it in 1kg bags in supermarkets, with an extremely streamlined and risk free distribution chain, it already costs about four times that price. Imagine how much would the markup be if it were sold by the gram (typical purchase a few grams), by random people on the streets, with a huge personal risk and maybe even cut with other substances to add mass, after having passed through three or four intermediaries. The retail price is probably x1000 the price of the shipping container.
- jacquesm 6y agoThere is a bit of a difference between a KG of sugar which is sold 'as is' vs a kilogram of pure Cocaine which will never reach the end user in that state. So on a KG of sugar those costs are a large fraction, on a KG of coke they are a very small fraction. The markup is so large because the market is happy to bear it and the risk of getting caught goes up as more people are involved which will typically happen near the edge. Drug lords are rarely captured, their minions more frequently and street dealers more frequently still. The street price reflects that and simple economics: competition in drugs sales is fierce, fierce enough to kill for. If they could sell it for more they definitely would. Ironically, the better the authorities get at seizing shipments the higher the street price will be compensating the drug syndicates to some extent for their seized cargo. > The retail price is probably x1000 the price of the shipping container. You're off by a factor of about 100.
- Udik 6y agoIt seems we agree. But then I don't understand why you said in you previous comment that > The street value is the only value they could possibly quote with some accuracy and > But I think if you discount by 50% or so you'll be pretty close When simple sugar is already sold by the kg with a 400% markup. > You're off by a factor of about 100. Sounds like you know what you're talking about :) But in which direction?
- nwallin 6y agoSuppose you are a reporter writing about an unusual accident where a shipping container full of canned tomatoes fell off a ship. Would you quote the value lost as the loss the farmer sold it for, the price the cannery sold it for, the price the importer sold it for, the price the distributor sold it for, or the price the grocery store sold it for? Every news outlet in the world is going to quote the grocery store price, #1 because it's a bigger number and that sounds more impressive, #2 because it's the only price any of their readers can relate to, #3 because depending on the exact structure of the supply chain every single price except for the grocery store price can fluctuate wildly, #4 because that's the way it's always been and you'll confuse your readers if you do anything different. Suppose you are a reporter writing about a drug seizure. Would you quote the total street price of the drugs, or --- how could you possibly be that familiar with the supply chain to quote any other price? If the transaction between the party doing transport and the party doing distribution has already taken place, the "real value" of the product has changed dramatically despite the fact that the container with the drugs is still the same thing in the same place. How can you tell what the "real value" is if you, the reporter, don't know whether or not it has been transacted? Even in the case of a supply chain where intermediate prices are defined in written contracts enforceable by law, it would be silly for a reporter to try to dig into what the "actual price" (finger quotes) of the product is instead of just using the street value. > And, conversely, if you were uninsured, what loss do you book in your accounting? The first loss, not the second. That's a tax writeoff. Accountants who book the first loss get fired and replaced by accountants who book the second.
- skissane 6y ago> Suppose you are a reporter writing about an unusual accident where a shipping container full of canned tomatoes fell off a ship. Would you quote the value lost as You'd look for an answer in a press release. If there is no press release, you'd ask the question at a press conference or interview, and then you'd cite the figure you were told without caring about how it was actually calculated. You'd likely only question the value if it sounded obviously wrong. > Suppose you are a reporter writing about a drug seizure. Would you quote the total street price of the drugs, or --- how could you possibly be that familiar with the supply chain to quote any other price? Does your average reporter actually know what the average street price of various illegal drugs currently is? Especially given the price varies from drug to drug, time to time, and place to place. I think usually reporters just quote the street value given in the law enforcement press release or news conference, rather than attempting to work out a figure for themselves. > That's a tax writeoff. Accountants who book the first loss get fired and replaced by accountants who book the second. Until someone gets charged with tax evasion.