4 ms·
Well, can you sleep on the street in an American city? Can you solicit charity? Are you allowed to eat a piece of bread to avoid dying of hunger, even if you ha
by tsimionescu 6y ago
Well, can you sleep on the street in an American city? Can you solicit charity? Are you allowed to eat a piece of bread to avoid dying of hunger, even if you have no money?
Or will the police fine you and jail you?
I don't agree with your reading of the original argument, but if you want to take it extremely literally, the police do actually force you to work, assuming you do not have money or relations to support yourself without working. And of course, the prison system will literally force you to work if you get that far. Of course, they are doing this through their enforcement of local, state, or federal laws, not by their own mandate, but they are still the ones ultimately doing these actions.
Of course, there are much more faitfhful readings of the original argument that have more nuanced responses.
- monksy 6y agoDepends on where you are, where the local law is, etc. "Allowed to eat a piece of bread to avoid dying of hunger" .. is there a law against it? I'm not sure what you're trying to get at. Our society is based on trade. They also have charities and shelters to help those who don't have it.
- throwaway894345 6y ago> Well, can you sleep on the street in an American city? Can you solicit charity? Are you allowed to eat a piece of bread to avoid dying of hunger, even if you have no money? In every major US city I’ve been to you can do this.