7 ms·
Off-topic, but it's hard to get the right feeling about the valuation given in drug busts. They say 100 million, but nobody actually lost that much money or pa
by colechristensen 6y ago
Off-topic, but it's hard to get the right feeling about the valuation given in drug busts. They say 100 million, but nobody actually lost that much money or paid that much money, and the drugs will just be replaced. The "wholesale" value of the drugs at that port may well have been 1/1000th of the quoted street price or less.
You get the impression that they like showing off big numbers, but it's difficult to be convinced that it ultimately makes a big difference, or even a positive one.
- darawk 6y agoThat's definitely the case. They always quote street values, which is ridiculous. But 2000kg is still a lot.
- PedroBatista 6y agoIt's not ridiculous because it's the "real" total value of the goods, which is what matters more than to know if the "owner" would receive X of Y.
- colechristensen 6y agoNo, the real value is the wholesale value at the port. What someone might pay to be able to pick up that amount at that place, or alternatively the marginal price i.e. what it cost to get the goods to that port. Is the “real” value of a field of corn ready to harvest the cost of the seed? the market price per bushel? the retail price of the tens of thousands of boxes of corn flakes? The value of anything accumulates with every action that is done to it and every piece of capital involved. A wholesale good at port is in the middle of that process and has not had all of its end value added yet.
- jacquesm 6y agoThey do mention it is 'street value', so it is properly qualified as far as I'm concerned.
- catalogia 6y agoI think this whole conversation is missing the forest for the trees. What matters is that it was worth enough to motivate torture. Quibbling over what number to put to that is missing the point.
- jacquesm 6y agoThe torture probably factors in on deals worth a couple of percent of that particular one.
- colechristensen 6y agoI knew this and the first thing i said was “off topic”, but i do think that quoting the street value exaggerates the effects of the bust and the pattern of communication distorting the reality in public announcements is worthy of debate. And yes, you can distort reality by telling the truth when you choose irrelevant facts for your main message. Lies, damn lies, and statistics.
- catalogia 6y agoThe number's contribution to the emotional impact of the story, far from distorting reality, is next to negligible compared to the part about torture.
- colechristensen 6y agoMaking a story sensational is distorting reality. The whole problem with drugs and law enforcement is that it has been driven now and in the past by emotional manipulation. Much of it was originally done by stoking racist fears, "reefer madness" and all that. If we were talking with reason instead of emotion, about causes and effects, about mitigating and minimizing negative outcomes, about giving people choices and recovery and ways out and in some cases ways to do things safely... a lot of real actual progress would be made. But that doesn't make sensational headlines, it's not simple or something that people can turn into a succinct cheer. Sensational stories start to be the goal of the government's "war", success measured in how much the story can impress the population. DISTORTING REALITY.
- vkou 6y agoThe real total value of a hand-full of sand is ~$400, because it can be refined into a 32-core Intel CPU. That is, if we completely ignore that most of that $400 comes from $400 worth of labour that needs to be put into that sand, to turn it into something people can pay money for. In that same vein, the drugs aren't (yet) worth $100,000,000, because you still need to put in millions and tens of millions of dollars of labour into them, to turn them into something people can pay money for.
- celticninja 6y agoNot the same here. The seized drugs are already processed and ready for sale to the public. There is no millions of dollars of labour required to split 2000kg into smaller and smaller packages to end up with 2,000,000 x 1g amounts. This is closer to entire wafers of chips being seized, which require some work to turn into a commodity for public consumption i.e single CPUs, but that is a lot less work, and less technical too, than creating the wafers in the first place.
- darawk 6y agoThere are millions of dollars of additional distribution risk, though.
- loeg 6y agoThese are just differences in degree rather than in kind. There is labor involved in processing the bulk powder: any cutting the seller wants to perform, partitioning into street sale sizes, and of course the actual sales, which is risky and time consuming. I think you are probably right that the ratio of labor and other costs favors Intel in this comparison, but I think arguing about the specific analogy here is an unhelpful tangent. The point is: published prices that ignore all of the costs involved in making the sales is a fiction.
- heavenlyblue 6y agoUm, why would cut your stuff at bulk level? It just becomes harder to transport. Cutting is mostly done by edge dealers rather than drug lords.
- alasdair_ 6y agoAgreed. For example, a kilo of cocaine in Los Angeles is around $17K. It's around double that in many other cities. Call it $25K as an average "street" price in major US cities (higher in those further from major trafficing routes). That gives a value around half of the amount quoted. To me, it seems like the police break everything up into half-gram prices and then add all those up. This would be like investigating the theft of 1000 gallons of water from a tap and then adding up how much the cost of that water would be if it was all converted to 250ml Evian bottles at retail.
- jacquesm 6y agoWell, it's street value so that's retail, though obviously if you are the owner of 2000 kg of cocaine you won't expect to make that much on it. Regardless, the amount here and it's value is so large that you can bet people would be more than happy to kill for it, it is no coincidence that this torture setup was discovered near Rotterdam. Even if the 'markup' is a factor of two. And that particular bust only stands out because of its immense size, 1200 and 1500 kg busts are relatively commonplace. The big question is how much of it gets through.
- celticninja 6y agoIf you consider that a 2000kg bust will have little to no effect on the retail price of cocaine you can assume that what gets through is a lot more.
- jacquesm 6y agoSafe bet.
- PedroBatista 6y agoThese "valuations" are important because they put a number on the whole "chain of value". Of course nobody would paid 100 million for that shipment, just like they didn't paid 80 million for the drugs. But you sure can bet if those drugs were bought and consumed, around 100 million would change hands ( total ), 10 million more 10 million less.. it's an estimation.
- oillio 6y agoThe bust doesn't change the demand at the market. The producers will provide as much as the market demands, taking into account the expected losses along the supply chain (losses such as confiscation). This only increases the cost of the suppliers. Which will be passed on to the consumer. As others have said, the war on drugs can only increase the price, and temporarily disrupt supply. I think it has been conclusively proven they are not capable of increasing the price above what the customer is willing to pay.
- heavenlyblue 6y agoIf they catch 5% of the market cocaine, then those 100 million would not have changed hands because if they didn’t catch those 100million worth of cocaine that cocaine overhead would never have been shipped. It’s not like people would suddenly start consuming more cocaine if police would stop seizing it.
- PedroBatista 6y agoThey would, just like they'll consume less if prices go way up. It's a relatively common occurrence these "shortages", but all of this to a point, people wouldn't consume triple the amount if there was 3x cocaine available. No one wants the streets to be flooded with cocaine, and I mean - no one - There's a reason why cartels are called cartels.
- elorant 6y agoJust because there are huge profit margins doesn't mean that there aren't people who were relying on pocketing the street value, or something similar. Whoever can move such vast quantities of drugs obviously employs hundreds of people who expect to get paid.
- colechristensen 6y agoThey also have a pipeline for delivering such quantities regularly and factor in loss to law enforcement just the same as retail prices in “shrink”. It is doubtful that a bust of that size is anything more than a regularly expected inconvenience. And honestly, reductions in supply means you can raise you prices and quite believably come out ahead. The war on drugs definitely makes the drug business more profitable.
- tomcooks 6y agoI think that if I were the head of a police department I would want to educate (or indoctrinate, depending on your view) citizens on the amount of money that drug cartels evade from taxation