6 ms·
Speaking as a former working-class person from a long lineage of working class people, this is obviously and overt nonsense. The criminal justice system and the
by throwaway894345 6y ago
Speaking as a former working-class person from a long lineage of working class people, this is obviously and overt nonsense. The criminal justice system and the (highly distributed) institution of policing in particular must be improved and reformed, but the idea that they "oppress working class people" in any meaningful way is severely disconnected from reality (well, communist countries notwithstanding).
EDIT: Wow, this post was downvoted the very moment I posted it (<1s). Good work HN.
EDIT 2: retracted claim that the parent was lying as opposed to the more charitable interpretation of their error.
- happytoexplain 6y agoI don't think you had to go as far as asserting that the parent is overtly lying. It's far from impossible to honestly believe the police "oppress working class people", especially if you have any personal experience to bias your view that way.
- throwaway894345 6y agoFair enough, I should have been more charitable.
- happytoexplain 6y agoI see you edited to remove the accusation of lying, but you left in "this is obviously and overt nonsense", which is pretty hostile and low value. Edit: You also added "as opposed to the more charitable interpretation of their error", which is very passive aggressive and elitist.
- deleted 6y ago[deleted]
- wolco 6y agoPolice come from working class backgrounds. It is usually the lower class not the working class who gets oppressed.
- Latty 6y agoYou complain about being downvoted, but your entire post is just calling the post "obviously and overt nonsense" and claiming it is a lie, without making any attempt to explain why. Not exactly a helpful post.
- throwaway894345 6y agoThere’s nothing to refute; the parent didn’t support their own claim. How can I prove a negative? Anyway, it’s overt ideological propaganda; I don’t owe a substantial response.
- JoeSmithson 6y agoWikipedia defines the police as "a constituted body of persons empowered by a state, with the aim to enforce the law, to ensure the safety, health and possessions of citizens, and to prevent crime and civil disorder". If you are claiming that the police are in fact, "a force which exists to terrorize working class people in order to force them to work for minimum wage" then I think the burden of proof is on you.
- Latty 6y agoThis is a very weird argument. No one is talking about the definition of the term, they are talking about the implementation as it exists in the US right now. This is like saying that just because the DPRK has "democratic" in the name, it must be a democratic nation.
- deleted 6y ago[deleted]
- happytoexplain 6y agoYou're misusing the concept of "burden of proof" as a rhetorical attack. The parent is not asserting the root comment to be true with no proof - they're pointing out why the response was bad. Upon whom the burden of proof lies has no bearing on that.
- 6y ago
- drunkpotato 6y agoYou're welcome! Just doing my part!
- makotech222 6y agolmao I'm a communist, and viewing police as an oppressive force in capitalist countries is bog-standard. Governments are a tool in which one class oppresses another class. In capitalist countries, the government is considered a dictatorship of the bourgeoisie, where business owners/landlords own the government, create the laws, and oppress the working class in order to maintain a class hierarchy. In communist countries, specifically those that follow Marxist-Leninism, i.e. Russia, Cuba, The working class seizes control of the government, and thus, it becomes a tool to oppress the bourgeoisie. The difference is, in capitalist countries, the working class is necessary to maintain the wealth of the ownership class, so the oppression must be stable but constant (using the police force). In communist countries, the bourgeoisie are NOT necessary for anything, and thus 'police' are used to oppress them until they do not exist as a class anymore. The gulags were an institution to reform bourgeoisie into working people (rather than just executing them). American prisons however, do not do any reforming, but keep and torture the working class prisoners in order to destroy their soul and extract profit from them.
- empath75 6y agohttps://www.jacobinmag.com/2014/01/the-bad-kind-of-unionism/ https://www.jacobinmag.com/2014/01/the-bad-kind-of-unionism/
- wittyreference 6y agoOn what basis is this comment getting downvoted to hell, in contrast to the comment it is replying to? Neither is any less an assertion without support. I'd argue this comment is, in fact, the less extreme and incendiary one.