3 ms·
> This was his dissent on DACA. Agree or disagree with the program that allows undocumented immigrants to stay and go to school, I don't care. It's not legislat
by masklinn 6y ago
> This was his dissent on DACA. Agree or disagree with the program that allows undocumented immigrants to stay and go to school, I don't care. It's not legislative, it's not judicial, it was a program by DHS setup under the last administration. Now the court rules the current administration can't undo the program? It's bizzare.
It didn't rule that the current administration can't undo the program, it ruled that the administration has to properly justify that decision, and not doing so is unlawful.
At no point did it rule on DACA itself, or prevent the administration from providing actual, motivated and legal reasoning for rescinding the program.
Also
> This was his dissent on DACA.
Which corresponds to the majority ruling on this case, yet I can't help but notice Gorsuch joined the liberal justices in the majority, not Thomas.
- twsttest 6y agoHowever DACA itself is unlawful in that it is an Executive Order undermining Federal immigration law, so the administration's rescinding it on the basis of its unlawfulness should be sufficient enough justification. The problem is that the Court's ruling indicates that an EO which subverts existing law cannot be overturned by subsequent administrations simply on the basis of its illegality. Justice Thomas' dissent says exactly this. That's incredibly problematic. According to the recent ruling therefore, a President has the power to issue and EO which prevents the enforcement of certain laws.
- brandmeyer 6y agoI urge you to read the SCOTUS opinion itself, and not just the rhetoric you may have heard in the media about the opinion. Because this: > According to the recent ruling therefore, a President has the power to issue and EO which prevents the enforcement of certain laws is flatly untrue.
- twsttest 6y agoIs it? DACA is unconstitutional in that it prevents enforcement of law yet now it cannot be repealed on the pure basis of its illegality. I want to be wrong, but I don't see how this isn't the precedent being set.