4 ms·
Does the nature of the crime in this case have any implications on the ongoing precedent? It's bizarre that the headline could have read: Rape-related SC Decis
by chiefalchemist 6y ago
Does the nature of the crime in this case have any implications on the ongoing precedent?
It's bizarre that the headline could have read: Rape-related SC Decision Returns Land to Native American Tribe.
- tony_cannistra 6y agoUnfortunately there's really no "return" of land. These headlines are siezing on the above technicality mentioned, which simply formalizes Tribal jurisdiction. The big news is precisely that formal recognition of Tribal (and, notably, treaty-conferred) authority.
- mason55 6y agoI don't think so. The rape case really just acts as a vessel to provide standing to litigate the larger question of the reservation. Without the rape case they wouldn't have had a reason to challenge the questions about the res but now that the Supreme Court has resolved the larger question it's applicable across the board. It could have just as easily been a case about shoplifting or murder or anything else. In fact, last term there was a case similar to this that was about a murder, where the defendant was sentenced to death by the state and they argued that the state didn't have jurisdiction. Gorsuch heard the appeal in the circuit court so recused himself from the SCOTUS case and the belief it was deadlocked 4-4, so they took this case and made the ruling with a full nine Justices.
- astrange 6y agoThere's a difference in that now major crimes between tribe members have to be tried in federal rather than state court. Minor ones would be tried by tribal courts, which already exist.