3 ms·
It's so weird how sentences so significant are often "protecting" the rights of terrible, terrible people: > McGirt, 71, has served more than two decades in pr
by toyg 6y ago
It's so weird how sentences so significant are often "protecting" the rights of terrible, terrible people:
> McGirt, 71, has served more than two decades in prison after being convicted [...] of rape, lewd molestation and forcible sodomy of a 4-year-old girl. McGirt [...] did not contest his guilt in the case
I'd be interested in learning who was involved in McGirt's proceedings and why. Did they mean to actually get this guy free (which, to be fair, at his age could be a charitable act in itself), or did they just think it was as good a chance as any to get this old treaty back on the table? There is a book and a film in that story.
- nabilhat 6y agoEveryone deserves a vigorous legal defense, even the most reprehensible. If the accused or convicted are exempt from the rule of law, so are those who are accused or convicted by mistake, corruption, or abuse of power. Competent and committed legal defense for everyone defends the rule of law as it's applied to all of us.
- djohnston 6y agoYep, but it also doesn't change that this particular person might be let free. I think it's OK to feel a little ambivalent about this ruling.
- yunruse 6y agoUnlikely. I can’t think of any immediate reasons that federal courts would consider anything different to the states, where something so heinous as rape of a child is concerned.
- tobylane 6y agoI think it’s not about his freedom, but one of the two courts that could charge him have the death penalty. His legal case is about avoiding that.
- toyg 6y ago> Competent and committed legal defense for everyone defends the rule of law I agree wholeheartedly, but in practice this often doesn't happen, for a multitude of reasons. Legal representation costs money in most countries, and most lawyers don't particularly enjoy defending guilty people (obviously they do it anyway, but it's a bit like having to fix a '90s PHP website when your passion is Python 3...). Hence my curiosity about the backstory of this particular situation going on for so long (20 years and all the way to SCOTUS is a lot of work).
- nabilhat 6y agoDefinitely on the same page. I'm just glad there are dedicated people doing the hard work to hold government's actions under the light of their own rules. There's way too much room for improvement in the system(s).
- staplor 6y agoYou should look into Ernesto Miranda. He did horrible things but the Supreme Court said that he incriminated himself without knowing his rights. Because of this, his conviction was overturned and now cops have to read ‘Miranda’ rights to everyone they arrest.
- ncallaway 6y ago> and now cops have to read ‘Miranda’ rights to everyone they arrest. This is a common misconception, but the requirement is not quite that broad. The police are not obligated to read you your miranda rights immediately upon request—it's possible that they might not at any point read you your miranda rights. What they cannot do is begin to question or interrogate you if they do not read you those rights. Any questions they ask without having read you those rights are at risk of being thrown out in court. Police will usually interrogate people after an arrest, so will often read them their miranda rights. (Edit: I also found out that any spontaneous statements you make are also fair game, if they didn't ask a question or prompt the statement) But, it's not an obligation for every arrest. If you are arrested the police might not read you your miranda rights, and your rights probably haven't been violated if they don't question you. If you are ever arrested, and interrogated, DO NOT TALK TO THE POLICE BEFORE YOU CONSULT YOUR LAWYER. Never, ever, talk to the police without speaking with a lawyer first. Here's an excellent video that explains the reasons why better than I can. I highly recommend this video: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=d-7o9xYp7eE&t=4s https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=d-7o9xYp7eE&t=4s
- falcrist 6y agoI just want to note that the thing being read is a "Miranda warning". The rights enumerated in the warning already existed. I was corrected about this a long time ago by a police officer who knew his stuff. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Miranda_warning https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Miranda_warning
- toyg 6y agoI do know about Miranda, I was tempted to mention him but I didn't want to end up implying this sort of sentence is always about bad guys - "often" was already a bit too strong for my taste.