3 ms·
When you file a lawsuit about it that makes its way up the courts.
by vkou 6y ago
When you file a lawsuit about it that makes its way up the courts.
- giantg2 6y agoEven if I had standing, it would never make it up courts because the oligarchy (judges) decide whether it is worthy or not. Just look at all the split decisions that SCOTUS leaves in place by declining to hear. Logically one of those two plaintiffs is being screwed.
- vkou 6y agoWorthyness only matters when the matter goes up to the SC. There are many layers of courts below them. If the SC decides the matter is not worthy, that doesn't mean that no decision is reached - it just means that the decision of the lower court is binding.
- giantg2 6y agoYes, but it may be based on a flawed precedent that only the supreme court can overturn. There are also many circuit decisions which conflict with each other that SCOTUS has refused to address. In these instances the court is allowing one of those two plaintiffs to be screwed.
- vkou 6y ago> is allowing one of those two plaintiffs to be screwed. Only if the SC would have ruled differently from the lower court, of which there is no guarantee for any particular case.
- giantg2 6y agoNo, it's split decisions from two separate circuit courts on the same issue with conflicting results. Basically one plaintiff from TX would be told 'yes, you have this right' while a plaintiff from NY would be told 'no, you dont have this right'.