3 ms·
Everything in audio engineering is about trade-offs and making the right ones. There is no driver, coil, MEMS, or otherwise, which can efficiently and accuratel
by bob1029 6y ago
Everything in audio engineering is about trade-offs and making the right ones. There is no driver, coil, MEMS, or otherwise, which can efficiently and accurately reproduce the entire range of human hearing at reasonable SPL.
For applications below 200Hz, there really isn't much better choice than a coil-driven speaker. You are limited to very low frequencies, so the relatively coarse mechanical nature of the coil speakers is more-or-less hidden by the fact that any higher frequency harmonics/distortion are designed out (crossovers, cabinet design, etc).
The best speaker is going to be a combination of various technologies. The current dream speaker for me would be:
- large array of plasma or MEMS-based tweeters (2KHz+)
- large array of 2~3" drivers (120-2000Hz)
- a handful of 18" drivers (20-120hz)
- a rotary subwoofer in an infinite baffle (DC-20Hz)
- DSP/equalizer/time-delay hardware+software for tying the whole thing together
Also note that the amount of power required to produce the same amount of perceived acoustic output as you go down in frequency goes up very quickly. 50 watts into a 18" subwoofer is going to sound fairly meek, but pipe that exact same electrical signal into a titanium dome tweeter and you will develop an instantaneous case of tinnitus.
- nitrogen 6y agoFor those like me who hadn't heard of rotary subwoofers: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Rotary_woofer https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Rotary_woofer I remember reading about a LCR speaker array that was built in the 1970s in someone's house, with horns that spanned the entire height of the room made out of cinder blocks. Don't really know how how I would dig that article back up, but it was a pretty interesting system.
- bob1029 6y agoA surprising amount of that content is still out there if you have the patience to dig for it. AVSForum used to be my primary reason for internet usage for about 2 years of my life. The DIY community is still extremely strong (probably stronger than it was a decade ago). If you have a few weekends, basic electronic & woodworking skills, and a $2000 budget to burn through, you can easily put together a 2.1 channel audio reproduction solution far more impressive than you could ever hope to buy off the shelf at any cost. I built a 800 liter subwoofer that plays flat to 13Hz back in 2008 for ~$600. Still works flawlessly to this day. The key is to be inventive with materials and design, and to always be aware of the space in which you will use the equipment. The room is always the most important part of the audio reproduction equation.
- willis936 6y agoYou can throw most of that conventional wisdom out for sealed IEMs.
- bob1029 6y agoIEM basically eliminates the room from the equation so I would have to agree with that angle. But, I would also argue that the IEM experience pales in comparison to the experience of having thousands of watts of electricity converted into low pressure acoustic waves for all in the vicinity to enjoy. Watch the bridge shootout scene from MI3 with some IEM on your smartphone vs at your local cinema with its commercial grade sound system. There is a certain level of physical immersion that is simply not possible with just an IEM/headphone setup. Sure, you could strap haptic feedback vests to yourself and put linear actuators in all your chairs, but for me that is getting to be too finicky to tolerate. I'd much rather tell my spotify app to cast to my HTPC and instantly be greeted with a wall of powerful full-range sound.
- willis936 6y agoI agree with the tactile argument. If audio systems are trying to simulate the sound pressure experience in its entirety, then IEMs fall short. For the OCD-fueled desire for accurate sound pressure reproduction at the human-world audio interface, I think IEMs are where effort should be focused. 50 year old audibility studies imply that the perceptible gains are marginal-to-none-existent, but who says that's always the point? ;)
- korethr 6y agoCurious why 2-3" for down to 120Hz, as opposed to breaking you your array down into a few more cone sizes for more bands, like say, some 8" for low 100s of Hz, and a 3" for high 100s of Hz into low 1000s of Hz before the tweeters take over. Or is your goal to minimize the complexity of the crossover network that would be needed to cleanly separate the the bands with minimal distortion and the "fun" of correctly lining up the physical phases of each of the different cones?
- bob1029 6y agoI was thinking more along lines of a passive crossover network that would be a pain to build. If the whole thing is digital with dedicated amps per band, going for as many as possible is going to be more ideal as you can just divide things up in DSP software and automate it to a large extent.