4 ms·
"Sollen" translates to "should" and not "will" That means there is a element of uncertainty there whether they actually will.
by atoav 6y ago
"Sollen" translates to "should" and not "will"
That means there is a element of uncertainty there whether they actually will.
- brummm 6y agoActually it translated to "have to", not "should" (which would more properly be "sollten").
- dathinab 6y agoBetter "will have to" .. "if the law is passed".
- this_user 6y agoI would say it more precisely translates to "are supposed to". Although it is clear from the actual content of the article that it would not really be a choice.
- qwertox 6y agoNo, "are supposed to" is less strict than "must". If the law passes, then they must allow the intelligence services to do this. Or "will have to" if they want to continue to be in the business.
- Youden 6y agoI'm learning German at a fairly low level so I ask this from the perspective of wanting to learn, not as a challenge. Wouldn't "have to" be "müssen"? In what cases would you use "sollen" to have a similar meaning? And "sollten" is either Präteritum or Konjunctive II, which as I understand it would both mean "should have", though in different senses. Why is that a more proper translation of "should"?
- r6203 6y agoMost of the times, "sollen" and "müssen" are interchangeable. However, there are fine nuances between the words. In that case, "müssen" is more direct and used as a command which has consequences when not followed while "sollen" is more of a prompt or demand that hasn't to be followed.
- brummm 6y agoSollten is indeed Konjunktiv.
- dirkt 6y agoFull text from the netzpolitik article: > Provider sollen Internetverkehr umleiten, damit Geheimdienste hacken können > Geheimdienste wollen Hardware bei Internet-Providern installieren, um Staatstrojaner in Datenverkehr einzuschleusen. Das steht in einem Gesetzentwurf zum Verfassungsschutzrecht, den die Bundesregierung nächste Woche beschließen will. Die Provider wollen keine Hilfssheriffs sein. > [...] > Konkret müssen Anbieter die Installation des Staatstrojaners „durch Unterstützung bei der Umleitung von Telekommunikation … ermöglichen“. So it translates to "would have to, if the law goes into effect unchanged".
- elisharobinson 6y agoso that roughly translates to the state should have access to my personal property( computer / data ) and should have the right to do so by any means necessary. that sounds much better do remember article 11 and 13 were drafts aswell.
- corty 6y agoYes, you are right, I'm sorry for the somewhat misleading translation. But I felt "should" instead of "must" would be more confusing, because that would sound somewhat like "the author would like that". Which he definitely doesn't. Anything longer wouldn't have fit the limit.