3 ms·
(the critical detail is contained in the full headline - "can charge restaurants") The commission is the cut of the "food price" that the delivery service gets
by mindslight 6y ago
(the critical detail is contained in the full headline - "can charge restaurants")
The commission is the cut of the "food price" that the delivery service gets from the restaurant, in addition to charging the customer-facing "delivery fee". So if the customer sees "Pizza $20, Delivery $5", and the restaurant is paying 30% to the delivery service, the actual breakdown is "Pizza $14, Delivery $11". It's misleading to say that the pizza costs $20 when $6 of that is actually a hidden delivery fee.
How this falls out depends on whether the listed food price was the same as the restaurant's list price, had been inflated by the delivery service. But continuing the example, with the cap we'd expect to see the explicit delivery fee go up to ~$10 (if customers will bear it), and the food price to end up between $14 and $20 depending on the market for the food itself.
> And the fraudulent number thing is a separate issue, totally unrelated to level of competition
My point there is that the services are only allowed to do this in such a misleading way by the restaurant signing a contract allowing them to do so (otherwise it would be straightforward fraud). Despite the presence of many delivery services, it would seem they're all pushing similar scummy terms. This is an indicator of a lack of competition.
- crazygringo 6y ago> It's misleading to say that the pizza costs $20 when $6 of that is actually a hidden delivery fee. No it's not. While some delivery sites do list higher prices than in-restaurant (arguably misleading), that's not the norm. And as long as they don't, then if a pizza is $20, then if you're eating in-house $6 of that is going to dining space, tables and chairs, plates and utensils, dishwashing, etc. If it's delivery, the $6 is going to the delivery service, which includes listings, website maintenance, etc. All businesses spread their costs out among customers in different ways. There's nothing misleading about it. And again, "scummy terms" in no way implies lack of competition. Not sure where you got that idea from? Tons of industries are full of scummy terms while competition is thriving. Scummy terms have nothing to do with lack of competition and everything to do with which marketing funnels and pricing strategies turn out to be most effective. It's mainly about consumer psychology.
- mindslight 6y agoYet take-out is also the same price and doesn't require any of that overhead. Although you are saving on a "tip", which is yet another weird fee attributed to a third party rather than waitstaff just earning straightforward wages - cost-responsibility-dodging is rampant in this industry. What's probably driving this dispute over commissions is that restaurants still need to pay for that dining space during Covid, so they're fighting over that "spare" $6. > All businesses spread their costs out among customers in different ways. There's nothing inherently "hidden" about it. The restaurant is front and center as being the provider of the food. The delivery service is explicitly stating that this food costs one specific price, and delivery another specific price. Meanwhile this breakdown is false and arbitrary, with a seeming goal of misleading customers about how much getting your food delivered actually costs. > And again, "scummy terms" in no way implies lack of competition. Not sure where you got that idea from? Effective market competition generally results in reasonable terms, due to many meetings of minds. A lack of reasonable terms shows there is not effective competition over the relationship. If a restaurant could instead sign up with a delivery service that didn't front-run their customers, they wouldn't take to writing exasperated blog posts about it.
- crazygringo 6y agoI mean, shipping prices when shopping online also aren't the exact cost of shipping your package. "Free" shipping when you hit a minimum order is still being paid for in the price you pay per-item. Pretty much no prices magically reflect true costs anywhere. Delivery is no different. I don't know why you think delivery deserves to be super-transparently-related-to-costs when literally nothing else is in business except sales tax. (Pizzerias also make a tiny or no profit on cheese pizza but waaaay more on toppings, and cinemas make most of their profit from popcorn and sugar water, not your movie ticket. By your logic, all these are equally misleading.) And your idea that competition results in "reasonable terms" is just wrong, I'm afraid. You're stating this as fact when it's not. There's tons of competition in airfares and in signing up for credit cards, but they're full of scummy terms. And restaurants objectively have lots of choices of delivery services to sign up with. In fact, there has never been a time in human history when they had more choices for delivery. Those are facts.