6 ms·
When something is too good I will always ask, what are the trade offs? On paper at least, it should be much more reliable than Coil Speaker. And this is my sec
by ksec 6y ago
When something is too good I will always ask, what are the trade offs?
On paper at least, it should be much more reliable than Coil Speaker. And this is my second MacBook Pro which has Speaker Crackling problem. ( Although it is more likely an Apple faults judging from Google Search )
- dsr_ 6y agoHere are the negatives: - unusual amplifier requirement - poor performance under 200Hz (mid-bass to sub-bass) - good volume for a headphone driver, terrible volume for an open air speaker driver It might go into your next AirPod, it won't go into your next MacBook.
- lukevp 6y agoIt looked like the spl levels at low frequencies were comparable to other IEMs, with a peak in the high frequencies surpassing the other IEMs, and at a lower THD. The peaks could easily be equalized within an active system. These seem ideal for optimizing small Bluetooth audio devices like the AirPod or hearing aids, so I don’t think any of your cons apply for this use case. I agree with the final statement, but it’s not clear that the first 3 are actually non issues in an AirPod scenario.
- entropicdrifter 6y agoThe peaks could also be tuned away acoustically with some foam with highly specific thickness. Would be pretty easy by high-end IEM standards
- willis936 6y agoAlmost all BA IEMs use in-line re-radiator “resistors” to smooth out peaks.
- quotemstr 6y ago> When something is too good I will always ask, what are the trade offs? Sometimes there aren't trade-offs. The thing about new technology is that it pushes out the "Pareto frontier", that configuration surface along which trade-offs happen. A classic example is the "fast, good, cheap" trilemma. You can imagine this trilemma as a geometric object (say, a hypersphere) and the particular "fast, good, cheap" trade-off you make as a point on the surface of that object. New technology makes the whole object bigger. Does the v0 technology have important disadvantages? Sure. LEDs started out being red and dim. Now LEDs are the "too good to be true" option, beating most other lighting sources most of the time in most domains.
- bob1029 6y agoEverything in audio engineering is about trade-offs and making the right ones. There is no driver, coil, MEMS, or otherwise, which can efficiently and accurately reproduce the entire range of human hearing at reasonable SPL. For applications below 200Hz, there really isn't much better choice than a coil-driven speaker. You are limited to very low frequencies, so the relatively coarse mechanical nature of the coil speakers is more-or-less hidden by the fact that any higher frequency harmonics/distortion are designed out (crossovers, cabinet design, etc). The best speaker is going to be a combination of various technologies. The current dream speaker for me would be: - large array of plasma or MEMS-based tweeters (2KHz+) - large array of 2~3" drivers (120-2000Hz) - a handful of 18" drivers (20-120hz) - a rotary subwoofer in an infinite baffle (DC-20Hz) - DSP/equalizer/time-delay hardware+software for tying the whole thing together Also note that the amount of power required to produce the same amount of perceived acoustic output as you go down in frequency goes up very quickly. 50 watts into a 18" subwoofer is going to sound fairly meek, but pipe that exact same electrical signal into a titanium dome tweeter and you will develop an instantaneous case of tinnitus.
- nitrogen 6y agoFor those like me who hadn't heard of rotary subwoofers: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Rotary_woofer https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Rotary_woofer I remember reading about a LCR speaker array that was built in the 1970s in someone's house, with horns that spanned the entire height of the room made out of cinder blocks. Don't really know how how I would dig that article back up, but it was a pretty interesting system.
- bob1029 6y agoA surprising amount of that content is still out there if you have the patience to dig for it. AVSForum used to be my primary reason for internet usage for about 2 years of my life. The DIY community is still extremely strong (probably stronger than it was a decade ago). If you have a few weekends, basic electronic & woodworking skills, and a $2000 budget to burn through, you can easily put together a 2.1 channel audio reproduction solution far more impressive than you could ever hope to buy off the shelf at any cost. I built a 800 liter subwoofer that plays flat to 13Hz back in 2008 for ~$600. Still works flawlessly to this day. The key is to be inventive with materials and design, and to always be aware of the space in which you will use the equipment. The room is always the most important part of the audio reproduction equation.