3 ms·
I would like some comments on this: I have been grappling with how to discuss issues related to covid as truthfully as possible, and I’m wondering if anyone di
by mensetmanusman 6y ago
I would like some comments on this:
I have been grappling with how to discuss issues related to covid as truthfully as possible, and I’m wondering if anyone disagrees.
My intuition as a physicist says that any discussion or comparison of covid effects that look at total numbers, while true, is less meaningful than looking at these numbers normalized by population size.
Both sets of numbers are true, both lead the intuition to different conclusions. What conclusion should the intuition land on?
Isn’t it strange that people can argue behind truthful data to lead people to completely different conclusions?
- phroobster 6y agoOften when I see numbers instead of percentages in these discussions, I can’t help but think it’s intended to manipulate the reader and that the percentage wouldn’t evoke the same emotional reaction.
- sbussard 6y agoIt makes sense to me (B.S. Physics, 2010) it’s easy to tell arbitrary stories with quantities defined up to a constant.
- raphlinus 6y agoBoth sets of numbers are meaningful, for understanding different parts of the problem. The spread of an infectious disease like Covid-19 is not a virus moving through a relatively homogeneous population, but rather the overlay of a lot of small outbreaks. Early on, when the total number of cases is small, absolute numbers are most meaningful as a basis for comparison. [1] is a thread from Mar 29 (from the brilliant visualization expert John Burn-Murdoch) arguing that absolute numbers are more predictive of "death toll one week after 10th death" and that normalizing by population only makes smaller countries look worse. But as the spread continues (a process which takes time), per-capita numbers make sense. Mr. Burn-Murdoch revised his position (see [2] for a podcast with transcript where he talks about his thinking), and now the FT graphs have a normalized option (though their focus has moved on to other metrics such as excess mortality). Carl Bergstrom also has a great thread [3] where he talks about the choice, concluding that both are valid as long as you're careful about context. HTH [1]: https://twitter.com/jburnmurdoch/status/1244380095164420101 https://twitter.com/jburnmurdoch/status/1244380095164420101 [2]: https://voices.media/transcript-john-burn-murdoch-senior-data-visualisation-journalist-financial-times/ https://voices.media/transcript-john-burn-murdoch-senior-dat... [3]: https://twitter.com/CT_Bergstrom/status/1249930293928030209 https://twitter.com/CT_Bergstrom/status/1249930293928030209
- mensetmanusman 6y agoIt sounds like we would ideally have a geographical heat-map overlaid on to every county in America that was per-capita based. Then, even small numbers in an initial outbreak are meaningful because you aren’t dividing by the population of the world. This would also let local policy makers and citizens gauge risk levels. It seems to me that the media scared everyone in the country in March/April based on what was happening in NYC, and now people are numb to any recommendations. This miscommunication cost us dearly.