3 ms·
There are legitimate abuses of market power. But this is not one of them. Nobody's forcing restaurants to enter these partnerships, there's competition, and de
by crazygringo 6y ago
There are legitimate abuses of market power. But this is not one of them.
Nobody's forcing restaurants to enter these partnerships, there's competition, and delivery people still need to be paid.
There are two obvious outcomes here: either food delivery apps will restrict delivery to profitable orders only (stop working for some restaurants, require higher order minimums, etc.), or they'll stay to avoid bad press but then this is essentially the city blackmailing investors to subsidize food delivery.
It's one thing for COVID-19 to restrict business services, and deeply unfortunate that businesses wind up closing. It's another thing entirely to force businesses to continue operating but at a loss.
If Portland or other cities believe it's a necessary public service to provide subsidized food delivery, then they ought to pay for it themselves through tax dollars. Either hire city-employed deliverypeople and make them available to restaurants, or pay GrubHub etc. to do it through a normal business contract.
But capping food delivery rates to far below what they were pre-pandemic is not a fair approach.
- mindslight 6y agoIt's amazing how many commenters have not read the article. This is not a cap on the total price of delivered food, but rather a restriction on the delivery service misrepresenting the price of the food itself. The obvious outcome is that the delivery services move their total fee into the appropriate line item labeled "Delivery Fee". Also, there is an apparent lack of competition in this space, given that restaurants end up signing contracts that allow delivery services to setup fraudulent phone numbers to capture customers that would otherwise have a direct relationship with the restaurant. Presumably the ordinance only applies during Covid times because afterwards the restaurants will regain a fair amount of bargaining power with their dine-in customers. Currently a restaurant can only see so many orders coming from a delivery service, and has no way of knowing how many of those customers would have been direct if not for the front running.
- crazygringo 6y agoHuh? I don't understand what you're saying at all. This is a cap on the commission charged. The article doesn't say anything about total price or about misrepresenting prices. Where are you getting that? Why are you saying people aren't reading the article? And the fraudulent number thing is a separate issue, totally unrelated to level of competition. It's scummy but irrelevant to this particular issue. Competition exists because there are multiple mainstream food delivery services and restaurants have been delivering food on their own for decades.
- mindslight 6y ago(the critical detail is contained in the full headline - "can charge restaurants") The commission is the cut of the "food price" that the delivery service gets from the restaurant, in addition to charging the customer-facing "delivery fee". So if the customer sees "Pizza $20, Delivery $5", and the restaurant is paying 30% to the delivery service, the actual breakdown is "Pizza $14, Delivery $11". It's misleading to say that the pizza costs $20 when $6 of that is actually a hidden delivery fee. How this falls out depends on whether the listed food price was the same as the restaurant's list price, had been inflated by the delivery service. But continuing the example, with the cap we'd expect to see the explicit delivery fee go up to ~$10 (if customers will bear it), and the food price to end up between $14 and $20 depending on the market for the food itself. > And the fraudulent number thing is a separate issue, totally unrelated to level of competition My point there is that the services are only allowed to do this in such a misleading way by the restaurant signing a contract allowing them to do so (otherwise it would be straightforward fraud). Despite the presence of many delivery services, it would seem they're all pushing similar scummy terms. This is an indicator of a lack of competition.
- crazygringo 6y ago> It's misleading to say that the pizza costs $20 when $6 of that is actually a hidden delivery fee. No it's not. While some delivery sites do list higher prices than in-restaurant (arguably misleading), that's not the norm. And as long as they don't, then if a pizza is $20, then if you're eating in-house $6 of that is going to dining space, tables and chairs, plates and utensils, dishwashing, etc. If it's delivery, the $6 is going to the delivery service, which includes listings, website maintenance, etc. All businesses spread their costs out among customers in different ways. There's nothing misleading about it. And again, "scummy terms" in no way implies lack of competition. Not sure where you got that idea from? Tons of industries are full of scummy terms while competition is thriving. Scummy terms have nothing to do with lack of competition and everything to do with which marketing funnels and pricing strategies turn out to be most effective. It's mainly about consumer psychology.
- 6y ago
- grumple 6y ago> There are legitimate abuses of market power. But this is not one of them. I’m curious. How long does a company need to lose money on each unit of work they do, funded by endless foreign vc money, before it’s clearly an abuse of their financial power and destructive for the market? No company can compete fairly against people willing to lose billions just for market share.
- crazygringo 6y agoExcept money is never endless. And consumers are benefiting in the process from cheap prices. So as long as consumers are benefiting, and the situation can't go on forever, where's the abuse? Abuse is generally a characteristic of natural monopolies, etc. Not merely a competitor with deep pockets. That's just healthy competition for the good of consumers.