2 ms·

Frankly that feels exactly like a Flash page. Natively selecting text content isn't supported on either Firefox or Chrome on Android (apart from within inputs).

Frankly that feels exactly like a Flash page. Natively selecting text content isn't supported on either Firefox or Chrome on Android (apart from within inputs). Scrolling is broken ("yanky"). Flutter for Web further feels like a nightmare for accessibility. I tried enabling the native Google screenreader on my device. It only says "No text found at that location" when I try to read any of the Flutter demo pages in either Chrome or Firefox. In addition to being extremely hostile to people with disabilities, it will soon actually be illegal to build new products with accessibility-hostile tech like Flutter for Web for large parts of the European public and private sector: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/European_Accessibility_Act https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/European_Accessibility_Act > we're still in beta From these viewpoints that feels more like an early alpha product. In 2020 no accessibility support is a non-starter.

mwcampbell 6y ago
About accessibility, you need to find the "Enable accessibility" button and press it first. It's not visible on screen, but you should be able to find it with your screen reader's navigation commands (e.g. swiping left and right on a touch device). Yeah, it kind of sucks that the user has to turn accessibility on, and for that reason alone, I will never willingly develop a web application with Flutter. But at least it does support accessibility.
- vesinisa 6y ago
  Right, to be fair I was able to enable the accessibility mode with your instructions. This way, the text content is indeed accessible to a screen reader. However, navigation in any of the demo apps with a screen reader was completely broken. So a user might be able to read a single page but not discover further content. With normal web pages we usually have <a> elements that enable navigation regardless of visual gimmicks.

mwcampbell 6y ago

About accessibility, you need to find the "Enable accessibility" button and press it first. It's not visible on screen, but you should be able to find it with your screen reader's navigation commands (e.g. swiping left and right on a touch device). Yeah, it kind of sucks that the user has to turn accessibility on, and for that reason alone, I will never willingly develop a web application with Flutter. But at least it does support accessibility.

vesinisa 6y ago
Right, to be fair I was able to enable the accessibility mode with your instructions. This way, the text content is indeed accessible to a screen reader. However, navigation in any of the demo apps with a screen reader was completely broken. So a user might be able to read a single page but not discover further content. With normal web pages we usually have <a> elements that enable navigation regardless of visual gimmicks.