30 ms·
GDPR says hello. Even something as easy as Google's recaptcha is impossible to implement GDPR-compliant according to many German authorities, so I highly doubt
by mschuster91 6y ago
GDPR says hello. Even something as easy as Google's recaptcha is impossible to implement GDPR-compliant according to many German authorities, so I highly doubt that this kind of invasive tracking is in any way legal.
Why can't they just use something like a proof-of-work mechanism to combat spam?
- eindiran 6y agoHow would the PoW mechanism work?
- superkuh 6y agoYou can see anonymous proof of work voting in action over at notabug.io.
- hombre_fatal 6y agoI was able to upvote something 30 times, myself. Like, the first point of an anti-spam system on a forum is so that you can't just upvote your own crap to the front page. Wonder why this never caught on. /s
- deleted 6y ago[deleted]
- superkuh 6y agoIt's the least worst system that allows for anonymous people to participate (no accounts required). Rather than stopping people the idea is to add just a little friction.
- hombre_fatal 6y agoTo say that, you're kinda assuming the objective though and then suggesting that it's a worthwhile one. Like, this poor solution is probably the best thing on some dimension, I would just wonder if it's a dimension worth caring about. The objective seems to be eliminating the requirement of registration at all. Why? Why would I care to enable people to upvote/downvote content that don't care to spend 1 second registering? I also don't think you can make a convincing case that the friction of registration makes or breaks any websites when almost all of the most popular websites require registration. Seems to be me users are willing to jump the hurdle by the millions if they care to engage. It can't be a matter of privacy because the site could be logging your IP address in both cases. It can't really be friction because you could make the most frictionless process possible. Maybe clicking upvote summons a tiny tooltip where you enter a username and password. EZBoard forums back in the day had that -- You would write your whole post and the submit button would assign you a random username that you could then customize. I just see a forum that made the questionable decision to let you infinitely manipulate rankings without even trying to stop you, the actual impl of that (no registration, PoW puzzle, etc.) rather irrelevant.
- deleted 6y ago[deleted]
- zemnmez 6y agodo you have a source on this? I've only seen assertions that recaptcha is against GDPR from US sources
- mschuster91 6y agoOnly in German: https://www.lda.bayern.de/de/faq.html https://www.lda.bayern.de/de/faq.html
- MauranKilom 6y agoTranslating the captcha-related items: > It it allowed to embed captchas that prevent bots? > Yes. The website operator has not only a vested interest in using captchas but is even obligated to do so as they have to guarantee website availability. (I don't understand what this obligation is about - surely it's my own choice whether my website is up or down?) > Is it allowed to embed Google captchas on the website? > Website operators should strongly consider alternatives. If Google reCAPTCHA is used regardless, the responsible should be aware that they must be able to prove that this use is lawful according to [data privacy law]. When unable to explain how Google uses user data, the user cannot be informed transparently and the lawful use cannot be established.
- kube-system 6y ago> (I don't understand what this obligation is about - surely it's my own choice whether my website is up or down?) They are likely either saying that the uptime of the service relies on the use of captchas (i.e. it's a technical obligation), or it is implying that the majority of sites are commercially operated, wherein the operator has a financial/legal/contractual obligation that they deliver a working product.
- callalex 6y agoI agree that this is gross, but I do want to add some subtlety to the discussion. Reddit is trying to combat a different kind of activity than traditional spray-n-pray “buy our pills” spam. It is a large and influential enough forum that corporate and nation-state actors try to manipulate the tone and content of conversation with both words and votes. None of that is necessarily a volume-based issue, which is what proof-of-work is effective against.
- toomuchtodo 6y agoReddit could require users associate a mobile number with their account and use an SMS to validate. Zelle (the payment network) performs fraud validation using your mobile number as a signal, for example (using a Google Voice, Twilio, or similar virtual number will cause onboarding to fail).
- lmz 6y agoAs if people won't complain about that, especially if they want a throwaway identity.
- deleted 6y ago[deleted]
- AnthonyMouse 6y agoA prepaid SIM card is $5. There are also now services that do this for you so you don't even have to buy the SIM card yourself. They add some new phone numbers every day and publish the numbers along with every SMS they receive on a public site with ads on it. The "higher end" ones give you your own personal throwaway phone number but then you have to pay the $5. This means sites should immediately stop using this verification method because it obviously isn't going to stop adversaries with even trivial resources, and the security implications of encouraging vulnerable populations to use random sites like that is hugely bad. SMS verification is also ridiculous to begin with because phone numbers get recycled quickly and users should neither lose their account just because their phone number changed nor have some stranger enabled to steal it.
- eli 6y agoSpammers don’t mind doing work
- hombre_fatal 6y agoEspecially when it's not their machine.
- nemothekid 6y ago>Why can't they just use something like a proof-of-work mechanism to combat spam? I don't believe there is a level of work that one could do that would both be too expensive for scammers and not grind your battery to a halt.
- superkuh 6y agoThis actually played out on the reddit-alike notabug.io (federated all js thing with proof of work anonymous voting). What happened was a couple users had the programming skill to write better than JS could ever be voting bots and then they controlled the "front page" and only looking at all posts by 'new' worked. This of course meant the anti-spam proof of work voting was not working and so useless.
- neilv 6y agoSeparate from GDPR, I'm wondering whether using security exploits (such as ones the article listed) will be considered violation of US law pertaining to unauthorized access of a computer system.