4 ms·
I don't understand the need for all of this obfuscation/gamification around the act of actually performing physical exercise. What works for me regarding on-go
by bob1029 6y ago
I don't understand the need for all of this obfuscation/gamification around the act of actually performing physical exercise.
What works for me regarding on-going daily exercise is rowing while listening to a podcast about something really deep (JRE, The Portal, etc.). It takes me exactly 60 seconds to get my shoes on, queue up a podcast and start into the rowing session. Anything longer than this would probably demotivate me to the point of not exercising regularly.
I strongly suspect the reason a lot of this fancy exercise gear is never used consistently is because there is always some UX annoyance that gets in your way - forgot safety key somewhere, need to update your treadmill software, have to review user manual, etc. In this attention deficit society, anything beyond 60 seconds might as well be tomorrow. You have to eliminate barriers to fitness, not create new ones.
A Concept 2 Model D rower can operate without electricity or internet. Its user interface is completely optional (assuming you already have the damper set appropriately). The mode of exercise is intuitive and easy to learn. These facts make it one of the most valuable pieces of exercise equipment that one can own. All you need is a can of 3-in-1 oil and you can make it last for an eternity. The only things you have to think about are your form and how much you feel like pushing your metabolic pathways. Everything else is optional. This is the best way to monotonically improve ones fitness. Consistency and ease of use. Distracting screens and wildly variable exercise regimes built upon social networking and gamification are moving entirely in the wrong direction.
- skizm 6y agoToo loud for apartments unfortunately. I've tried a few exercise machines (bikes, rowers, and air bikes), but Peloton is pretty much the only thing quiet enough for an apartment. I wish I could have a rower and assault bike, but my neighbors would kill me, and I wouldn't blame them.
- Retric 6y agoAssuming you have enough sound insulation to watch TV at normal levels, just put some foam pads under exercise equipment and it’s fine in most apartments. At the extreme end barbells are completely silent.
- bob1029 6y agoIf you have a C2 with clean rails & rollers and a thick rubber mat under it, it should be virtually inaudible to downstairs/adjacent neighbors. Also barbells can be the ultimate silent form of exercise if you are skilled in their usage. I can do most lifts more quietly than when I am rowing. Dropping the barbell, or explosive lower body movements are usually the only 2 things that should ever make loud noises, and one of those should never happen if you are doing things properly. I also don't think it is unreasonable to make a little bit of noise during waking hours, especially if it's only for ~30 minutes at a time and not of an impulsive nature (i.e. dropping things on the floor). A C2 would probably be mistaken for a washing machine when listening through a wall.
- redisman 6y agoI got a water rower (it has a water tank for resistance) and it's pretty quiet. I use it in my apartment (in the hallway so it wouldn't really bother anyone even if it was louder).
- novok 6y agoHave you tried an exercise bike with magnetic resistance? They're pretty cheap and near silent.
- mauvehaus 6y agoI don't disagree with you, but Peloton is definitely a thing. Maybe they're doing the UX better than everybody else, but I have a friend who wasn't into riding a stationary bike before she got one, and she's really into riding all of their rides "through" various scenic places now. EDITED TO ADD: Also: you're approaching this like a set of arbitrary components you plug together: An exercise machine and the entertainment. Maybe for some people it's easier when they're together and you don't get one without the other? I mean, I can listen to a podcast without getting on a rower (or exercise bike, etc), but if you can't "ride" the scenic routes without your Peloton, I can see that being a motivator for some people.
- kevmo314 6y agoAlso to OP, definitely just try it before you knock it. I also thought Peloton was kind of silly then one day I had the opportunity to actually try it. I wouldn't say it fits in my workout plans, but it was fun and it was a workout. I get the impression a lot of the criticism levied here comes from people who have never even tried these experiences.
- nateburke 6y agoConcept2 is one of the most interesting businesses out there. C2's production is largely still in the USA, with quality paramount. The PM computer, I think, is done overseas. Profits are slim. How have they not ended up like Cannondale Bicycles? (production shipped to China in late 90s, with quality inevitably suffering)