10 ms·
Spot does have that problem. Back in the 1990s, before Boston Dynamics had legged running really working, I was looking at that and running simulations. The onl
by Animats 6y ago
Spot does have that problem. Back in the 1990s, before Boston Dynamics had legged running really working, I was looking at that and running simulations. The only market that looked reasonable was toys. A $1000 toy seemed marginal. The Sony Aibo was in that space, and it was withdrawn. Sony had a follow-on humanoid, but it never shipped as a product.
I met the designer of the Furby and found out what its manufacturing cost is. Let's just say it's less than a meal at most fast food places.
Big Dog and the Legged Squad Support System were impressive, but not useful. The USMC rejected the LS3 and bought small ATVs instead. Much more practical.
(Reminds me of the U.S. Army's flying saucer, the AvroCar. That was a disk-shaped aircraft that was supposed to be a flying Jeep. It was unstable, underpowered, and couldn't get out of its own ground effect. Really cool, though. The Army had another project at the same time, the Utility Helicopter program. That resulted in the UH-1 "Huey", one of the most successful helicopters of all time, with over 16,000 made and many still in use after six decades. It's not exotic but usually will get you there and back.)
- beambot 6y agoI heard through the grapevine that SoftBank sold something like 22,000 Pepper robots at $12k each. I never understood the utility -- I only ever saw them used as chintzy marketing gimmicks. I could easily see 1000 qty sales of SpotMini for the cool factor alone -- i.e. research labs, corporate labs, startups, etc without ever finding a real "value" application. This drives me nuts as a roboticist & CEO of a service robotics company. But so it goes -- at least it's better than their past product: Youtube Videos.
- ivankirigin 6y agoYour company https://cobaltrobotics.com/ https://cobaltrobotics.com/ is really cool. I think it highlights that a vertical with specific needs can be met with the right hardware. No need for a face or arms.
- beambot 6y agoThanks for the kind words.
- Animats 6y agoIf BD/Softbank could get the price of Spot down to $12K, it might sell. Softbank might even subsidize that to grow the market. That's what Softbank does, after all. What the world needs is a good US$5000 assembly robot. Universal Robots has a good one for $23,000. Nobody is building good robots in high volume. Not even Foxconn, which tried.