3 ms·
Seems like the most compelling evidence of racially-disparate treatment is that she got no responses when reaching out via her own email address, but received s
by gnicholas 6y ago
Seems like the most compelling evidence of racially-disparate treatment is that she got no responses when reaching out via her own email address, but received some responses when reaching out via her husband's (he is an Asian-American man with a recognizably Asian name). Assuming the emails sent were identical, this would be pretty solid evidence of bias.
One potential confounding issue is that her husband is a former Google engineer, and she doesn't mention having any similar experience. It wouldn't be surprising if a VC's vetting process involved checking linkedin to see what experience the person had, and giving points to former FAANG engineers (note: I am not in this category).
Regardless, it's still pretty lousy that VCs that claim to want to help certain types of founders don't even respond to inbound inquiries.
- bigpumpkin 6y agoAny particular instance is not proof of racism. But I suspect VCs as an industry is biased against Black people because of its closed network nature and the lack of black founders in general for the VCs to pattern match. This should be especially acute for early stage investing when much relied on intuition and the "quality of the team".
- phnofive 6y agoI’m curious about the email thing too. If she was using the ceo@bright email in the blogpost, I can see that getting filtered before any human read the contents, otherwise it’d be foolish to not give the time of day to a person who fits their advocacy profile, regardless of the business’ viability.
- oh_sigh 6y agoHer name is "Nerissa Zhang" - unless they are looking through for profile pictures of her or something, wouldn't they assume she is Asian as well? At least for me, "Nerissa" is a name of unknown origin, maybe Greek. Zhang is clearly Chinese. I would assume the person was Chinese or at least 50% Chinese if I was forced to guess about their race/ethnicity.
- gnicholas 6y agoI assumed that since she claimed the email experience was evidence of bias, that her last name didn’t appear as Asian as her husband’s. You’re absolutely correct that if her email shows up as Zhang, that makes her email bias claim much weaker.
- jbay808 6y agoDo people usually change their email accounts when they marry and take their partner's name?
- 9HZZRfNlpR 6y agoYou can route old account emails to new and answer people from new account. It's quite seamless, to new people you give the new email. At least I knew few people who have done it after name change, but marriage and taking new name is less common nowadays than it used to be I guess.
- huffmsa 6y agoSo they're vetting out black women because they haven't had the necessary experience, because hiring and funding is biased against them, particularly because they haven't had the necessary experience. See the problem here?
- daseiner1 6y agoit’s not VCs responsibilities to cultivate people worthy of VC-level funding. and from all the college outreach i’ve seen in the past several years, FAANGs are absolutely desperate for women and minority engineers. companies are doing plenty
- thinkindie 6y agoShe reached out to VCs that pledged to support the Black community of founders. Beside the fact that we have seen VCs pouring money into all possible kind of failing business (WeWork anyone? Wag?), you can't require the same profile parameters from an underrepresented community otherwise their pledges were empty. If they spotted some of the weak points that many found in this discussion (poor product reviews etc), they could have at least provided an honest feedback, some contacts or else. I guess that before money, these cases are showing no interests at all in supporting Black founders (sometimes intros or contacts are way more valuable than money).
- zentiggr 6y agoMaybe its VCs responsibility to respect what they say in public and give disadvantaged founders the extra support and consideration they said out loud in public? Companies can't be doing plenty if they say 'we will help this imbalance' and then don't.