2 ms·
The argument against self-signed certificates seems to be that people will get a false sense of security because they think that the connection is 'secure.' How
by pyre 16y ago
The argument against self-signed certificates seems to be that people will get a false sense of security because they think that the connection is 'secure.' How about accepting the connection but not displaying the normal visual cues that say "this site is secure?" (e.g. the lock icon) Is that a significantly worse alternative?
The argument that encryption without authentication is useless seems to be too focused on the security of the connection. The larger the percentage of network traffic that is actually encrypted the less 'suspicious' encrypted connections look. In general, this is a state of affairs that we want to get to. Using encryption shouldn't make you stand out from the general population.
How is connecting to a site using HTTP any more secure than connecting to a site with HTTPS and a self-signed certificate so long as the user is not presented with any indication that the site is now 'secure?' Even better, how about having an icon that is always in one of two states: "secure" or "insecure." So now the user is presented with something that indicates "insecure" even when they are browsing over HTTP. This more accurately represents the state of affairs. The way browsers present security to the user currently is more along the lines of:
HTTP => I can browse the web and login to Facebook
HTTPS (CA-signed cert) => I can now use my credit card
HTTPS (self-signed cert) => ZOMG! I'M BEING HACKED!