3 ms·
> The way the EU usually works is that they say "we are concerned about X, Y and Z's effect on our citizens" to industry, and industry responds "we'll self-regu
by AnthonyMouse 6y ago
> The way the EU usually works is that they say "we are concerned about X, Y and Z's effect on our citizens" to industry, and industry responds "we'll self-regulate to ensure X, Y and Z do not have the effect you're concerned about".
The problem in this context is identifying adtech as the industry rather than the adversary. It's like identifying a problem with spam and then asking the spammers to self-regulate. It's misapprehending the nature of the problem.
So then you say the spammers wouldn't self-regulate by not spamming so we're going to regulate email. Everybody hire a lawyer if you want to use email. And then the spammers still give you the finger because the internet spans the globe and they just set up in countries that won't enforce your rules, and the rules increase costs on everybody else.
What we need here are technical solutions. Browsers that resist tracking and fingerprinting. Technology to resist correlation attacks. The dissolution of unitary identity systems. More software that runs on your machine and not the adversary's machine. Make tracking too hard and there is no more tracking industry.
The thing most needed there is funding. There is profit in tracking and not so much profit in anti-tracking, so if you want anti-tracking then provide money for it. And for goodness sake stop passing laws against anti-tracking measures.
- vertex-four 6y agoI'll point out that the EU Government has poured an incredible amount of money into the problem of "privacy and enhancing trust" and related topics - if you're in the EU, even as an individual developer you can likely get some of that money through NLNet. Unfortunately it's a hard problem and the other side has a lot of money too.