5 ms·
Why would having a larger pool make dating harder? I think the author is confusing the probability of a “stable marriage” with the probability of a relationshi
by EGreg 6y ago
Why would having a larger pool make dating harder?
I think the author is confusing the probability of a “stable marriage” with the probability of a relationship.
What this says is you’d expect cheating to go up. As Chris Rock says, “you’re only as faithful as your options.”
- arvarik 6y agoRight, I should have made that a bit clearer. Modern dating is harder because the pursuit of a stable marriage is harder. Although this is all assuming people date to get married.
- mistersquid 6y ago> Although this is all assuming people date to get married. Tongue firmly in cheek, I bet a not insignificant number of people get married to stop dating.
- wolfram74 6y agoThere's one simulation I'd have very much liked to have seen the results of, and that would be the female preference advantage under the paretto-normal asymmetry. When you have a normal-normal preference, you'd assume the advantage to be equivalent for whoever was reaching, but that assumption isn't as well grounded when the distributions aren't equivalent. TLDR: do the women have a similar advantage if they are the reachers?
- arvarik 6y agoSo there's two reasons why there is a male preference advantage here: 1) I ran the algorithm assuming the men make the first move and 2) Male/female normal/pareto correlation in attractiveness Do you mean what would happen if the distributions were switched but men still make the first move? I could change up the script and run it again if that's what you mean!
- wolfram74 6y agocalling it male/female at this point is kind of arbitrary, when it's the asymmetry in the distributions that I thinks interesting, but yeah, what happens if the pareto-preference population was the first mover rather than the normal-preference population that acted first. It's well documented that the first mover in the stable mariage problem has an advantage, It's why they switched from residency programs to being first movers to med students being first movers about a decade ago for The Match. This is the first I've seen it done with different preference distributions in the population. I'm curious how strong of effect the advantage is for different distributions.
- cupcake-unicorn 6y agoHey there, sorry to comment hijack - I really enjoyed this article. Was not aware of the Stable Marriage Problem and the associated algorithm and real life applications with medical students/roommates. Appreciated the humor and memes as well :) I noticed thought you don't list any email or anything if I had further questions - is there a good way to get in touch? Thank you
- deleted 6y ago[deleted]
- arvarik 6y agoThanks! :) You can connect with me on LinkedIn which is linked at the top of the site!
- Spooky23 6y agoIt's in the article. Basically, dating in our modern world of few meaningful social connections is a vicious cycle for women. Men rate attractiveness on a normal distribution, women rate attractiveness on a pareto distribution. (ie. 80% of men are "meh" or worse to women.) I've seen this in action in my personal and professional lives. Smart, attractive women end up implementing (knowinginly or unknowningly) a complex rules engine for screening an endless pool of available men. (Male criteria for engaging a woman online is very low.) When you are a 29 year old female only considering seriously dating attractive jewish/catholic/athiest, asian/black/hispanic/irish/white/etc men 6'1" or taller in professional jobs (generally speaking or a specific gig) who have attribute X, Y, or Z, you're screwed. Men will usually stop filtering earlier. They still get into awful relationships, but they don't filter out 80% of the population.
- toomuchtodo 6y agoI don't think it's solely a lack of meaningful social connections, although that's a contributing factor. Women have more choices and are more picky versus historically, and men are economically disadvantaged due to globalization and wealth/income inequality. Here's a comment where I opine on this from a previous thread on the topic: https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=22407388 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=22407388
- Spooky23 6y agoI think the hockey stick growth of online dating is directly correlated to reduced social activity. "Bowling Alone" captured part of the phenomena 20 years ago. That hasn't changed. Even things like little leagues and soccer clubs for kids are declining in many ways and much more commercial activities than they were in the past. Even worship has changed -- high growth religious services are scaled-up entertainment and child care focused vs. community. Personally, I don't buy into the notion that people have changed. People are people. I think the environment has changed and people are playing interacting with it based on the funnel they get sucked into. The online dating services are listing real estate agents -- their interest is in a higher number of conversions per customer. They will optimize for that metric over time.
- theFeller00 6y ago>why would more choices make making a decision harder fucking what?
- colmvp 6y ago> Why would having a larger pool make dating harder? FWIW, I have found online dating way harder than dating someone I met through friends/work/school. YMMV but my theory is having access to that many more people leads one (including myself) to sometimes think there's someone more attractive/interesting out there instead of giving what's available to them a strong chance. I have two good friends who have been serial daters for years and they have Seinfeldian reasons as to why they didn't fit with someone. It made me think my God, "if everyone had your standards, literally no one would have a long term relationship." Interestingly, when I saw them date mutual friends back in Uni, the relationships were the longest they've had their entire lives. I'm convinced that a lot of stable marriages from people I know around me wouldn't have happened if they had tried first meeting online instead of happenstance in IRL situations, because person A wasn't the typical ethnicity that marries person B, or person A is much older than person B and wouldn't have fit in the filter, or person A isn't particularly photogenic, etc. I'm not trying to paint online dating as a bad thing as there are quite a number of success stories.
- mensetmanusman 6y agoThis. I come from a strong family culture (dozens of cousins, off-spring, good communication, >95% stable long-lasting marriages, etc.), and we were taught that there is no perfect match. Love isn’t a feeling, it is an act of the will for the good of the other. Ergo, it’s your job to make the relationship work. Millennials without robust world-views haven’t yet figured out that the ‘fear of missing out’ is devastating to their pursuit of happiness.
- watwut 6y agoMillenials and young people are not more promiscuous and don't jump from relationship to relationship. They are more likely to be single or have long relationship. But less so trying out many partners. Also most Millenials are over 30 now.