4 ms·
> One just cannot be as expressive in markdown as one can be on a blank dotted-grid page and a pen-pot of Tombow double ended brush pens and Pilot V5s. Counter
by paulcole 6y ago
> One just cannot be as expressive in markdown as one can be on a blank dotted-grid page and a pen-pot of Tombow double ended brush pens and Pilot V5s.
Counterpoint: Yes they can.
There’s this weird fetishization about paper notebooks. It’s like the people who say that vinyl is unequivocally better (it’s not).
For some people the end result of digital notes is vastly superior to anything they can scribble in a notebook.
- nsomaru 6y agoExcept, vinyl fundamentally solves the same problem as another medium of storing audio. Paper offers a different level of expression. The comparison is thus not equivalent. Usually when you offer a counter point you don’t just disagree, but provide some basis or example to show the statement or proposition in question is false. Fetishising notebooks aside, parent mentioned expressiveness. Clearly everything that can be _expressed_ in Markdown can be expressed on paper, but it’s not clear that the opposite is true.
- asdff 6y agoThe difference is there is literature and research to support paper note taking as superior to digital in terms of comprehension and creative thought. If you've indexed your notebooks, it isn't hard to go back find relevant info years later.
- gorgoiler 6y agoAs far as end results go, obviously My Life And What I Learned Along The Way.pdf is obviously going to win out over a pile of scribbles. Regarding my original point, it’s what you use to get to the finished product that counts, and I maintain that hacking markdown is inferior to freeform pen and paper thinking.
- nitrogen 6y agoDo you have a good system for drawing diagrams and plotting graphs in Markdown? Maybe some hybrid of dot, octave, and latex?
- prepend 6y agoI use mermaid.js for graphs and charts in markdown. It takes a long time, related to pen and paper, so I don’t use it for note taking. But it’s really nice for procedural documentation.