6 ms·
I think you've just illustrated revisionist revisionist history. The original text is true. The Concorde was what the airlines, aircraft makers, and the public
by reaperducer 6y ago
I think you've just illustrated revisionist revisionist history.
The original text is true. The Concorde was what the airlines, aircraft makers, and the public wanted. It was fast. It was expensive. It was a trophy project. All things that appeal to one or more of those segments.
What changed was that fuel got too expensive, deregulated airlines started cutting corners everywhere, and people's priorities changed.
The world went from people wearing their Sunday suits to embark on a flight to people piling into Southwest air buses in their pajamas without bathing.
So the history is correct. It's just that the world has changed.
/Flew on the Concorde in the mid-1990's.
- michaelt 6y agoWhy did airlines want Concorde to be expensive?
- reaperducer 6y agoThe airlines didn't. The aircraft makers did.
- rbanffy 6y agoNobody wanted. It's just that the technology to make it less expensive didn't exist. Better engines and more range could help a bit, but it'd still be more expensive than cramming a lot ot people inside a 747.
- gsnedders 6y agoIn 1972, at list prices, 24M for a 747-100 and 34M for a Concorde, which is a fair bit more expensive… and then that's _vastly_ more expensive per seat.
- rbanffy 6y agoIf the plane can fly twice as often, it has, effectively, double the capacity. Still, supersonics will need some major breakthrough in operational cost.
- selectodude 6y agoThe priority for people was never getting somewhere supersonic. BA needed to fly what amounted to subway service between JFK and LHR in order to make SST worthwhile to the very, very small subset of people who could afford it. However, due to how small that subset was, they were flying a dozen half-full flights per day. If they cut back on the number of flights, they removed the time savings of the Concorde and it was cheaper and far nicer to just fly an overnight flight on a 747. Didn't help that it had the hourly mx requirements of a fighter jet.
- bobthepanda 6y agoYup. There is a reason why Boom Supersonic is only targeting a plane that comfortably seats 50.
- notahacker 6y agoThe Concorde wasn't what the airlines, aircraft makers, and the public wanted by the stage the followup project was cancelled because airlines wouldn't buy it, the aircraft maker hadn't sold any and some of the few routes of the first gen aircraft kept open flew mostly empty.
- jariel 6y ago"The Concorde was what the airlines, aircraft makers, and the public wanted. It was fast. It was expensive. It was a trophy project. " There's a difference between aspiration and market reality. 'The Public' never actually wants a 'Trophy Project' to the extent that they are not willing to actually pay for it out of their own pockets. Yes, they might like the idea, but what matters is "are people willing to pay the price"? I suggest there was probably a lot of hubris in the project, that said, there's probably a lot of demand these days for such a thing. There are a lot of hyper-rich people and they desperately need status. Also, in Finance, there are a lot of 'important people' who's time is actually valuable. With long-flight times what they are, doing an Atlantic or Pacific run 'very fast' actually is just 'worth it' even for the company paying for it.
- reaperducer 6y agoThere's a difference between aspiration and market reality It was a market reality for 27 years — longer than most of the companies that employ people who post on HN.
- notahacker 6y agoThe market reality was that it had only two customers operating only two routes for much of that time whilst most of the aircraft those customers had essentially been given sat on the ground. And it wasn't for lack of unsuccessful experimentation with other routes.
- jandrese 6y agoIt was propped up by governments for 27 years as a source of national pride. One can argue that they got a lot more value out of it than the equivalent amount of money spent on fighter jets and bombers though, and those are just as much prestige projects.
- HPsquared 6y agoThe R&D probably also was somewhat shared with the supersonic nuclear bombers of the same era. Much like spaceflight and ballistic missiles.
- WWLink 6y agoWere you a business executive flying on a corporate flight? I was under the impression that the vast majority of concorde passengers were flying on behalf of their employer and had a very high position at their company. Eg the kind with escorts and possibly white powder being served up at their business meetings. o_O Didn't know average people flew it.
- lb1lf 6y ago-'Average' people got to fill the seats not taken by the rich and famous on occasion. (I flew it once - BA 747 LHR-JFK, Concorde JFK-LHR, mid-nineties. The round trip was organized by an aviation magazine, once the ‘wow, I’m on the Concorde’ novelty wore off (a couple of minutes after going supersonic), the experience was rather underwhelming. Glad to have experienced it, though.
- kortilla 6y agoThe “public” isn’t people willing to put on business suits to travel. The “public” wanted to be able to afford to travel and that’s not what the Concorde brought. The “public” you’re referring to is the small 0.1% of the population that gets annoyed when Delta One is sold out.
- lumberingjack 6y agoThey used to advertise Concorde in movies with lines like "did you know the Concorde will get you there in half the time?"
- Someone 6y agoReading https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Concorde https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Concorde, it was partly the world changing, but also budget overruns and the sonic booms. Also, part of “the world changing” was that the 747 appeared, a plane that Concorde couldn’t really compete with, economically. Also, it seems the bill for development of the Concorde was paid for by the governments of Great Britain and France, and wasn’t fully accounted for in the unit price. If so, that made it a much more attractive proposition. I also would think some airlines placed pre-orders in a defensive move (if it had become wildly successful, airlines flying slow planes could get in trouble) I doubt any manufacturer would have dared to design and build a supersonic plane if they had to have to pay for all development (Boeing had a competing project (https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Boeing_2707 https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Boeing_2707), but that, too, seems to have been heavily government sponsored)
- ghaff 6y agoIn some ways, the 747 was also designed for a different world. The hump housed a first class lounge originally. https://www.pinterest.com/nickverreos/747-upper-deck-flying-in-style/ https://www.pinterest.com/nickverreos/747-upper-deck-flying-... But when business class came in, it got converted into an upper deck of business class seats in most configurations.
- craz8 6y agoBritish Airways equipped that section as Economy for many years. It was like flying in a short 737 up there!
- eternalban 6y agoThe Shah flew the Concorde and apparently liked it so much, ordered 3 (Condorde 'B') on the spot. Typically ahead of his time, his vision was for making Iran a major hub along the lines of what Dubai and Qatar have done in the interim. Interesting to note that China apparently also ordered Concordes. https://www.nytimes.com/1974/06/29/archives/shah-of-iran-reported-to-shift-to-firm-orders-for-concordes.html https://www.nytimes.com/1974/06/29/archives/shah-of-iran-rep...