5 ms·
> However Harvard and MIT aren't all about caring about their international students here. They are also thinking heavily about the money they might be losing.
by PragmaticPulp 6y ago
> However Harvard and MIT aren't all about caring about their international students here. They are also thinking heavily about the money they might be losing.
It’s okay to have multiple motivations.
The fact that they have a monetary incentive doesn’t detract from the good of what they’re doing. In fact, that’s partially what enables these expensive lawsuits.
We shouldn’t try to downplay good actions just because money is also involved.
- seamyb88 6y ago> We shouldn’t try to downplay good actions just because money is also involved. I disagree. When there are thousands upon thousands of innocent people in privately-run ICE detention centres, whose economic value is solely based on their being locked up, it doesn't go nearly far enough to say that THESE immigrants are worth fighting for because their economic value is based on their relative wealth. So you consider it downplaying, I consider it attempted betterment.
- nsm 6y agoOne can do some good (even for selfish reasons) and it can be commendable. One isn’t obliged to solve the entire problem. https://blog.jaibot.com/the-copenhagen-interpretation-of-ethics/ https://blog.jaibot.com/the-copenhagen-interpretation-of-eth...
- dominotw 6y agoThats exactly how big pharma is usually defended. Access to elite society is controlled by these institutions so if they have money motive then they perpetuate rich-> rich cycle.
- s1artibartfast 6y ago>Thats exactly how big pharma is usually defended. And it is a legitimate defense. Big pharma, motivated by profit, has brought countless medicines to market and saved hundreds of millions of lives. Non-profit pharma does not have the same track record.
- dominotw 6y agosure. My comment's assumption was that, A. people defending harvard's money motive here B. people defending harvard's money motive elsewhere don't have a big intersection
- s1artibartfast 6y agoThat is an interesting take. I would assume that almost everyone in group B would also be in group A. Group A would also have situational supporters outside B
- minerjoe 6y agoDo you really live in a world where Big Pharam is a force for good? I live in a world where many of my friends and even my father was killed in cold blood by that system in its blind pursuit of profit over health and honesty. The number of people harmed by perscription drugs when there are less damaging, and often times natural and cheaply available and more effective, non-patented treatments is astronomical and ongoing.
- nickff 6y agoDoctors are at least partially to blame for poor prescription practice; they have a much stricter duty to their patients. Doctors are also pursuing profits (as evidenced by their high incomes); they just don't aggregate the wealth into a single entity which can be targeted by class-action lawyers.
- xxpor 6y agoThere's nothing inherently good about something that's "natural". This sounds like the nonsense Steve Jobs was following before his death.
- rjkennedy98 6y agoYes of course natural things can be bad and unnatural things can be good. That is totally beside the point (and a total straw man). We obviously live in a world where natural remedies can't be commercialized the way Pharma drugs can. This creates incredible incentives to push dangerous medicines on people and the expense of everything else. America is the most drugged society in the world - and it also is one of the most unhealthiest. That is not an accident.