3 ms·
This falls into the area of ethics under extortion. e.g. consider the act of paying a bribe. Scenario 1: You pay the bribe and make 10x the amount due to fast
by mensetmanusman 6y ago
This falls into the area of ethics under extortion.
e.g. consider the act of paying a bribe.
Scenario 1: You pay the bribe and make 10x the amount due to faster govt. processing.
Scenario 2: You pay the bribe to save someones life who will die otherwise.
Paying the bribe in Scenario 1 is immoral and paying in Scenario 2 is moral.
Dealing with China is more akin to Scenario 2.
The Catholic church is the oldest institution in the world, it knows it can wait.
- thinkingemote 6y agoAs the late Terry Pratchett wrote in his book Small Gods, "....the truth is too precious to die for..."
- onion2k 6y agoGiven how wealthy and powerful the Catholic church is, and how much the people who run the church would like it to stay that way, I suspect it's not just Scenario 2.
- mensetmanusman 6y agoThe Catholic church doesn’t globally pool their wealth. “ In 2010, the Vatican had an income of $326 million and ran a $13 million budget surplus, but in 2011 the Vatican ran a $19 million deficit. And while some of that money obviously went to maintaining church buildings and art, much of it also went to charitable causes. Recent re-evaluations of Vatican assets show that the Vatican has approximately $1 billion in total assets. For comparison, Harvard University’s endowment is over $30 billion. So, relatively speaking, the Catholic Church is not really wealthy, and no one blames museums for maintaining their art work and structures. “
- onion2k 6y agoThe Vatican owns more than 71,659,919 hectares of land around the world, mostly in prime areas of cities. A single hectare in London is worth 7 or 8 million dollars alone. Then there's the massive amounts of gold, buildings, art, etc on top. I can believe the Vatican itself, as in the tiny city state in Italy, is worth $1bn, but the Catholic Church owns hundreds of billions of dollars worth of assets. If they evaluated it all at just $1bn then they lied.
- mensetmanusman 6y agoThe Vatican does not own more than 71 million hectares of land... You might be confusing the Vatican with the Catholic Church.
- onion2k 6y agoYou might be confusing the Vatican with the Catholic Church. It's a semantic difference that has no real meaning. Every Catholic church organisation answers to the Vatican. Treating them separately is like treating Apple, Apple UK, and Apple Ireland separately because no, really, they are different legal entities honest.
- dragonwriter 6y ago> The Vatican owns more than 71,659,919 hectares of land around the world No, it doesn't. Catholic institutions do, perhaps, but the relationship between other Catholic institutions and the Holy See is complicated, both legally and by tradition and more practical concerns. > I can believe the Vatican itself, as in the tiny city state in Italy, is worth $1bn I think the reference here to the Vatican is to Holy See, of which the State of Vatican City is a subordinate component. > but the Catholic Church owns hundreds of billions of dollars worth of assets The Catholic Church is not, as such, a juridical entity and thus, as such, does not have the capacity to own anything.
- amanaplanacanal 6y agoThere is also a scenario 1.5: if you don’t pay the bribe you can’t do business at all. The moral implications of that are undecided.