4 ms·
The NYT has fallen into the bad habit of writing to a narrative, conscious or unconscious, rather than investigating more honestly. In this case they want to p
by mc32 6y ago
The NYT has fallen into the bad habit of writing to a narrative, conscious or unconscious, rather than investigating more honestly.
In this case they want to paint the alternative path as wrongheaded and foolhardy. I’m glad someone tried something different in light of a lack of hard evidence. Time will tell if one or the other was better, but at least we’ll have baselines to compare against.
- dmix 6y agoLooking at the John Hopkins graph a significant amount of countries are still peaking (including the global trendline): https://gisanddata.maps.arcgis.com/apps/opsdashboard/index.html#/bda7594740fd40299423467b48e9ecf6 https://gisanddata.maps.arcgis.com/apps/opsdashboard/index.h... Just because a few countries in Europe and the early big ones in China/SK have slowed down they act like it's over. Yet there's still plenty of very major outbreaks in South America, Middle East, India, Russia, south east Asia, some African. They all have upward hockey stick growth still. Not to mention the delayed US south/west wave. It's far too early to pick winners/losers of COVID in the midst of the global peak, assuming this is actually near the peak. Let alone measuring the economic consequences.
- freetime2 6y agoYup I found the overwhelmingly negative tone of this article off-putting. It doesn't quote any opposing viewpoints. It doesn't quote anybody actually living in Sweden, or any sort of public opinion polls on how Swedish people feel their government is handling things. It only compares Sweden's death rate to countries with lower rates (when countries with higher rates exist). And it seems to paint a straw man argument about what Sweden's reasons are for not implementing lockdowns (I don't think it was just about the economy). It also doesn't delve very deeply into why Sweden's fatality rate is higher than average. It seems to imply that it's all because Sweden didn't implement forced lockdowns. But I am living in an area that also didn't implement forced lockdowns, and we have experienced virtually no deaths from covid in my city thus far. What measures specifically could Sweden have taken to save lives? And is there anything that they did well? I have found a lot of the coverage on covid to be fairly sensationalist (ranging from "it's all a big hoax" to "the world as we know it has ended"). Does anyone have any suggestions for more rational, honest, and detailed coverage of covid?
- belorn 6y agoThe first image people are greeted with in the article says everything needed about the editorial nature of the article. It is: It is taken of the area which has one of the lowest covid-19 death rates. Compared to its nearby city in Denmark it even has a significant lower rate of deaths. It is taken over the wrong time period. Both nationally and locally in that area, the death rate is going down. The image is from a few weeks ago during the warm weather when the rate was almost the lowest point of the whole measure period of the pandemic. The trend in that region is still downwards. It is the wrong demographic when talking about death counts. In Sweden the wast majority that died occurred in elderly care homes in low social economical areas, not young people on the beach located near expensive and hip restaurants in the second highest social economic area. But it makes for a great narrative tool, which illustrates the editorial values of NYT.