11 ms·
At some point, the collective tech community needs to develop a serious alternative to the current reality of a single corporation controlling the overwhelming
by keiferski 6y ago
At some point, the collective tech community needs to develop a serious alternative to the current reality of a single corporation controlling the overwhelming majority of a) online video content and b) online content in general (via search.) Online video is in its infancy now, but within a few decades, it will have become the modern equivalent of the book. Do we really want a single Kafkaesque, politically-biased entity controlling which books can be published?
Presumably/hopefully this will happen when storage becomes cheap enough to easily host video and someone figures out a way to filter through all the undesirable content which currently afflicts free-speech-oriented alternatives.
- andai 6y agoDoes the second half of your post not contradict the first?
- keiferski 6y agoIn what way? By ‘cheap enough to host video’ I meant in a distributed way, just as it became easier for more publishers to print books when the cost of paper/ink/presses went down.
- controversy 6y agoIt’s the filter out part that is seemingly contradictory.
- keiferski 6y agoI don’t have a problem with users choosing to filter out certain content. I have a problem with a single corporation or entity deciding what should be deleted (not simply filtered) for me, without my input or choice. The issue then simply becomes one of labeling. You can remove or relabel content for mislabeling itself, but not for being controversial.
- andai 6y agoOh you just meant let the user filter out content they don't want to see? I thought you meant the platform would remove it, hence my confusion.
- AnIdiotOnTheNet 6y agoSomeday tech people will have to realize that there are some problems that can't be solved with a website. We already have several alternative means of distribution for content, and searching that content, that are quite mature and successful. There is a huge community of people hosting, indexing, searching, and sharing all kinds of media in a distributed peer-to-peer fashion, for instance, the vast majority of it just happens to be pirated. The real problem is that such distribution mechanisms are not a way to make money, and you aren't going to solve that with a new algorithm. People have tried, it doesn't work.
- ghaff 6y agoYes. It's a solved problem from a technical perspective. However, as with individual blogs and websites, discoverability is fairly poor. And, in the case of video in particular, not only is individually hosted content not monetized in general (unless you're a subscription site of some sort or beg for donations), but it can actually be fairly expensive to do at scale. The issue is that many people aren't really looking for a way to host their videos; they're looking for someone to host their videos for free, with easy search, and to actually pay them money.
- asdff 6y agoIt just goes back to considering who your target audience is in order to market your blog. There is no reason why niche blogs should lean on SEO/target ads, when they could more effectively just directly advertise in like minded niche placements and capture their desired base. If you have a website full of videos about car repair, buy ad space on vwvortex forums. You can't ever possibly know all the disparate secondary interests of your target audience (although FANGs are trying to model this), so stick with what you know, your niche.
- Wohlf 6y agoMy thoughts exactly. And beyond just payment, the network effects are massive.
- djsumdog 6y agoI recently started running a peertube instance at https://battlepenguin.video https://battlepenguin.video I don't have a lot of stuff on YouTube/Vimeo and none of it has ever gotten a lot of views, but I am in the process of uploading old videos to my peertube instance and changing all the embed blocks on my website to show my peertube video instead and just have YouTube and Viemo below it as Links under a section labelled "Mirrors" on each of those posts. For big content creators that depend on the ad revenue, I realize it really isn't practical to mirror everything on PeerTube. Even if you know how to run your own peertube server and keep up with security updates, now you're eating into your own ad revenue (with the advantage of keeping your videos online in case the YouTube robots and/or gods decide to take down your channel). It's a double edge sword, but I hope more content creators will mirror their videos on services they pay for and have more control over.
- _curious_ 6y ago"I hope more content creators will mirror their videos on services they pay for and have more control over." I think this is the key...using the YT up/until you no longer can and then (presumably once an audience is present) reverting to your backups/hosting and going 'indy'.
- joedevon 6y agoOr retain shorter, teaser content on YT for marketing and a link to the full content on your main platform.
- giantrobot 6y agoThen YouTube just downranks your teaser content and you end up effectively invisible.
- whywhywhywhy 6y ago> Online video is in its infancy now, but within a few decades, it will have become the modern equivalent of the book We're already there. When you want to learn how to do something where do you go first?
- sam_lowry_ 6y agoDefinitely not Youtube.
- sempron64 6y agoI don't use Youtube for detailed technical documentation, but I watch a lot of conference talks and lectures on technical topics. I also like to watch other people programming to pick up their small tricks and the details of their setup. This is invaluable information that would otherwise be inaccessible except by acquiring it by chance at the workplace, a meetup, or a conference. Youtube's the first place I go to learn about any topic I'm a beginner on, especially topics which require manual skills, like home repair, automobiles, playing an instrument. It is a repository of the informal knowledge of mankind that is unprecendented in scale, breadth, and probably depth. It may be more revolutionary than book-learning in how it has disseminated knowledge to the world, and large parts of it would have incalculable value in being preserved. I only wish the Internet Archive had the sort of resources necessary to back up Youtube, but that seems unlikely to happen given the huge amount of storage necessary.
- elboru 6y agoNot even to know how to create, disassemble or repair something in your house/car?
- _jal 6y agoYou must live a very different life than I do. Video has so very many problems... - search doesn't even deserve to be called 'search'. I search on a well-known name from the news, Youtube shows me results from a band for a video I watched a month ago. - you must consume a nontrivial amount of a video to determine if it is any good. - information density is terrible. - most people are not practiced at being on camera, and you end up focusing on that rather than whatever you wanted to learn. - You can't reference things. What are you going to do, build your own index of '&skip=' links? - people feel the need to be funny, cute, or worse get a marketing budget and feel the need to create a "brand" with the time you're trying to use to learn something. - copy/paste. Enough said. - and so on. If video were somehow optimal pedagogy, there would be no arguments about reopening in the face of Covid - we'd all just watch TV. In conclusion, video sucks.
- cm2187 6y agoI don’t know that you need to filter anything. I think the solution is to move away from centralised platforms into self hosted decentralised channels where the owner of the channel controls their own content. Naively I see three obstacles. 1) cost + technical complexity, but that could be overcome through time, kind of like you have many platforms today that give you a way to create your own blog in a few clicks, and the cost of storage and bandwidth will only go down. 2) revenues. You kind of need an advertising platform (and then we are back to the google monopoly) or a payment platform (visa/mastercard/paypal oligopoly) 3) marketing, which I think is probably the easiest part. You lose the organic traffic of the next video suggested, but it is easy to do cross website subscriptions (rss style), and if people can share your videos through social networks or messaging, you can still have some powerful ways to pass the word (plus advertising). 2) is the one I am the most pessimistic about.
- lebuffon 6y agoMarketing drives revenue so... 3
- MaxBarraclough 6y agoMichael Moore's solution to a YouTube takedown (a copyright dispute) was to switch to Vimeo. [0] Seems to have worked in that instance. Doubtless the film got far fewer views, as YouTube is not only a video-delivery engine but also a video-discovery engine. (Shouldn't need to be said, but this is not an endorsement of Moore's film. Also I can't comment on the legitimacy of the copyright complaint, it's quite possible it's legitimate in that instance.) [0] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Planet_of_the_Humans#Release https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Planet_of_the_Humans#Release
- jasode 6y ago>Michael Moore's solution to a YouTube takedown (a copyright dispute) was to switch to Vimeo. [0] Seems to have worked in that instance. Sometimes Vimeo will also delete your channel. Example: https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=20347254 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=20347254
- pjc50 6y ago> Do we really want a single Kafkaesque, politically-biased entity controlling which books can be published? Have you met actual book publishers? And while KDP is pretty unfiltered, it's also kafkaesque and has its own weird little spam and infringement problems.
- marvindanig 6y agoA future with KDP is worse than with traditional publishers because there is at least some competition with the traditional model.
- whatsmyusername 6y agoStorage isn't the problem. It's transmission. Reliable Bandwidth isn't cheap.
- zozbot234 6y agoStorage is a problem too if you're anywhere near YT scale.
- whatsmyusername 6y agoGet to YT scale, then solve that problem. You're going to run into transmission problems waaaay before that.
- worldofmatthew 6y agoBandwidth only needs to be fast for video, aka it can be very cheap.
- dkh 6y agoIt's not cheap at all if you intend to create a playback experience that is tolerable to users and somewhere close to what they expect and are used to from existing platforms. If your video has even a couple seconds of buffering/rebuffering from failing to do this, you typically can say goodbye immediately to a percentage of views/users in the double digits.
- martin_bech 6y agoCouldnt you fake this? A really good spinner/loader experience, or perhaps a preroll prefetched video while buffering. How i remember netflix in the old days, the DA DANG clip seemed to be a preroll clip before the movie.
- dkh 6y agoAny sort of delay or buffering can affect you very negatively (see: https://mux.com/blog/buffering-reduces-video-watch-time-by-40-according-to-research/ https://mux.com/blog/buffering-reduces-video-watch-time-by-4... and https://mux.com/blog/rebuffering-the-most-frustrating-and-frequent-problem-for-video-consumers/ https://mux.com/blog/rebuffering-the-most-frustrating-and-fr... )especially now that most YouTube users no longer are used to it. Sure, you could do something like you mentioned, but doing this for every single video is not likely to go well. But very clever! And helpful, I'm sure. Not a true solution most of the time. I do very much enjoy the Chrome side-scrolling dinosaur game that appears when I'm offline, but I don't enjoy it more than once every few weeks :)
- marvindanig 6y ago> …it will have become the modern equivalent of the book. Strongly disagree with at least that statement. If we combine all three parts of Peter Jackson's Lord of The Rings, it still can't match the depth and length of Tolkein's work. Also, given that less than 3% of the book market actually reads digital file sold as a book, I'd say tech community in general is way off the course here. Ground reality is a lot more complicated than 'video is the new book' or 'blog is the new book'.
- dkh 6y agoUnfortunately, there are a number of things at play here that overall results in progress towards anyone being able to be "their own YouTube" very difficult. * Storage costs have decreased over the years and will continue to do so, but video quality has increased during this time, as well as the number of delivery formats you need to create. For each video uploaded, you likely need to encode and store 5+ different variations. * Bandwidth is not cheap, and while it may be lower than the cost of storage initially, for any chance of survival you'll eventually need some popular content, at which point its cost of delivery will exceed that of storage * To prevent the video from buffering and provide an experience that is tolerable to the average user, you need to have all of the above replicated on a dozen edge nodes around the world, and serve a user the video they've requested from the one nearest to them. This is a situation where the latency differences here really can make or break the entire thing There are numerous ways to try to optimize these things, or filter out costly/undesirable content, or prioritize only things that people are actually watching, or whatever, but few that come without consequences or that will cause bigger problems down the line.
- dvfjsdhgfv 6y agoFortunately, all these can be reasonably dealt with for niche videos (say, <10k plays by month). You could keep a collection of a few thousand of such videos on one Hetzner box for €20-30 a month (skipping wouldn't be smooth, put normal playback should be). This would make sense for small orgs though, not individuals.
- barrkel 6y agoWhat's needed is some kind of almost insurance scheme so that the long tail of content can be served up, but if a video goes viral, it doesn't become completely unavailable. Needs care with adverse risk selection, because freeloaders who want cheap video bandwidth for god knows what will crowd around.
- anderspitman 6y agoThat's an interesting idea. Could default to slow performance served directly off your laptop, and if it goes viral the network automatically moves it to a CDN at no extra cost to you. As an extra bonus, whatever small fee you pay to buy in isn't a complete waste of money, because presumably you get value from the viral content of others, ie as a consumer of their content.
- roadbeats 6y agoIt's not enough to develop though, people need to want it and use it. I think the problem is the later one. Or may be, the bigger challenge is not the engineering of such a platform but the marketing of it...
- AtHeartEngineer 6y agoI'm seriously considering making a reddit competitor with some significant tweaks to the karma/voting/mod system
- syspec 6y agoSounds like a great idea, might I suggest Hacker News as a name?
- AtHeartEngineer 6y agoLol I wouldn't want to soil these grounds
- throwawaynothx 6y agoI don't you understand, he's saying it exists and its hacker news.
- djsumdog 6y agoThere are a couple in current development you can contribute to. Look at Lemmy and Lobste.rs. There as Prismo too, but it's been discontinued (but you might be able to pick up and fork the code).
- AtHeartEngineer 6y agoCool thanks. I might have to start from scratch just because of the underlying mechanisms that I'd want in it. The premise is to use microtransactions for posting/comments, mixed with a bit of the patreon model, to reward good posts and have a barrier to entry for reposts/trolling.
- basch 6y agoMay I suggest a way to weigh votes. Either "count voters who vote like the people I follow" or "elect seed voters for a community, and extrapolate votes based the seeders and people who vote like the seeders." It would be cool to be able to sort a comment section, with a dropdown, between "best", "like people I follow", "like /r/askhistorian seeds", "like /r/askscience seeds"
- lovvtide 6y agoTake a look at Satellite. https://satellite.earth/ https://satellite.earth/. Launched last month. https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=23558483 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=23558483
- bane 6y agoThere's been a few youtubers who've tried to go elsewhere with their content. My guess is that given a viable alternative a huge number of them would jump ship entirely. The challenge for alternative youtubes is that they don't have the tight integration into their own ad network which is how google can afford to host lots of long-tail media and provide a sustainable service. However the flip side is that youtubers are all fighting with ridiculous cuts in revenue over time, bans, copyright strikes on the wrong content, and so on. And the number of videos of youtubers complaining about this comes in huge surges. In other words a lot of youtube content is creators talking about problems with youtube.
- knowhy 6y agoI doubt that video will become the modern equivalent of the book. Written text is still the best medium to transmit information. For entertainment purposes sure. But video probably already dominates that domain since we have more than 3 TV channels. Electronic repair might be a special case but I claim that a blog post with a bunch of annotated photos makes a more practical repair guide. People make YouTube videos nowadays because they can be better monetized. I agree with you, it is not a nice development, but I don't see free speech endangered because of that. (Google dominance in the search market is of course another story)
- deleted 6y ago[deleted]
- nine_k 6y agoDid you consider the fact that writing a good blog post with a ton of photos is going to take much longer than shooting and preparing a video? You need to write, edit, and proofread the content, while you can just speak as you go while shooting a video. You need to sort through a ton of photos and annotate them, while you can do with a worse quality video, because the motion helps perceive the details in imperfect conditions, and annotate much of it by voice? Some tricky parts of repairing stuff can be more easily shown in a 20-sec video clip than by 15 well-made annotated photos, the latter taking way more time. I think for certain areas, like the electronic repair stuff, video may be not just the most adequate medium we have, but also the fastest and easiest-to-produce medium.
- libertine 6y agoI think you're mixing everything together. >you can just speak as you go while shooting a video You're comparing a "good blog post" with a unscrippted/uneddited "video log". It's not the same - it's comparing Louis Rossmann VS iFixit. One is a form of educational entertainment, or entertainment, other it's a guide. You can learn from L.R., but it's not a step by step guide. You don't need to go back and try to find time stamps, you don't have issues of not understanding something that got muffled by him moving, you can miss a reference, etc. If you're talking about video guides, then they are scripted and will for sure be harder to edit than a blog post. There's a place for everything, and production costs (SHOULD) reflect on quality - the medium is irrelevant.
- castratikron 6y agoMaybe I am being naive but could this not be accomplished with simply a self hosted website with links to torrent files of the videos? Nobody can take down your personal website (relative to what youtube can do now), and distribution by torrent solves the bandwidth and storage problem. Of course, not as convenient as streaming, and you lose the comment section (is that truly a bad thing, though?), but it is a viable solution that can be implemented right now. People are talking about "alternative" websites as if they will find some magic bullet on that path. But who will create that website? Who will maintain it? And if the answer to those two questions isn't "me", how can you guarantee that the same problem won't eventually happen?
- andrewxdiamond 6y agoThis approach has issues with discovery. The hardest prt about producing content these days is getting people to watch it.
- castratikron 6y agoSometimes I miss the days when the internet wasn't one great big monolith and you had to discover things organically through word of mouth. But those days are gone.
- andrewxdiamond 6y agoMaybe, but having a pipeline to get people to content is overall better for everyone involved. So many creators would have no audience (or revenue) at all without YouTube and its (often touchy) algorithms. EEVBlog is a good example of content that wouldn’t exist without youtube. Dave is a full time youtuber who can focus on creating content instead of making money some other way. Dave is trying to move away from being dependent on YouTube, and he absolutely should, but he built his audience on YouTube in a way that isnt feasible in a world without algorithms pushing content towards people
- Taek 6y agoEverything comes down to UX. If you don't have a strong UX, you aren't going to be able to accumulate users. A webpage pointing to a list of torrent files is mechanically sufficient, but isn't going to be able to accumulate users.
- dominotw 6y agowhat about 1. credit card monopolies that kick you out. 2. dns servers like cloudfront
- ssalazar 6y agoVideo hosting is a solved problem, there are multiple mature and viable competing services. Creators use Youtube because of built-in discovery, community-building, and monetization services, which benefit much more from network effects and are harder to replace.
- zmix 6y ago> At some point, the collective tech community needs to develop a serious alternative to the current reality of a single corporation controlling the overwhelming majority of [...] I think we all can agree on this. The question, however, is: What is gonna pay for it? Especially the transmission of videos is very expensive. And while I would believe, that a lot of nerds would sacrifice resources to keep a P2P form of a specialized content distribution network running, it would not reach more than a few: the nerds themselves.
- etrabroline 6y ago>it would not reach more than a few: the nerds themselves Couldn't that have been said about the World Wide Web itself in 1994? Peer-to-Peer distribution only doubles the bandwidth required on a per peer basis. I don't think most broadband internet connections are >50% saturated by a youtube video.
- zmix 6y ago> Couldn't that have been said about the World Wide Web itself in 1994? And for a long time, it was! Let's not forget, that the novelty/impact of Internet ("a new world, we need it!") and an abstract concept like a "net in the net" is very much different. While the former is cool, the latter is, well: "who needs that", the average person says? You don't need seperate distibution networks for Facebook and Twitter, email, shopping and the web. And that's where the majority of the people wannt to hang around. Yes, Netscape was around, when Microsoft introduced IE, but it really came to everybody with IE and Outlook Express (otherwise, the net would still be a more refined and better mannered place, I dare say).
- etrabroline 6y agoI don't think implementation details matter. Isn't the Facebook backend a private 'net in the net'? What matters is the ability to create high quality content, and that's something 'nerds' tend to do a lot of. People only hang out on the big platforms because that's where the 'cool' people were in 2005.
- staycoolboy 6y agoI've been working with Mastodon, but it is REALLY hard to get people to use it because it is too small. I'm trying to get friends to join, but the response to me has been: "Too much effort, just use Facebook, dork." I don't think we've figured out how to build a distributed social media network yet that matches the ease-of-use and scale of Facebook. I'm hopeful though.
- perlpimp 6y agoJust because youtube is obtuse about video take downs, it should pay out supposed lost income during take down and it should take refundable escrow for flagging malicious content. Suddenly it will cost money and provide financial trail to abusive parties. Leading to fiscal responsibility in case of lost income greater than that might be covered by youtube if mentioned above scheme is implemented.