3 ms·
I think this sort of thing reads as absurd in Christian majority cultures mostly because mainstream Christianity does not currently have many restrictions which
by rsynnott 6y ago
I think this sort of thing reads as absurd in Christian majority cultures mostly because mainstream Christianity does not currently have many restrictions which inconvenience people day to day. Back when it did, they did stuff that was at least as weird; did you know that both beavers and certain types of geese were regionally considered to be fish to get around the no meat on Fridays thing?
- rbanffy 6y agoA very non-practicing Jewish friend of mine joked that he went to the local butcher, pointed to the pork and ordered, while pointing, "that fish". Growing up with those restrictions seems to do wonders for one's sense of humor.
- slavak 6y agoIn Israel it's affectionately known as "short cow".
- compsciphd 6y agoalso if you are used to asking for white meat in the US when talking about birds, please don't try to be smart and translate that into hebrew.
- ajuc 6y agoThere's a celebrity catholic fundamentalist nut in Poland that shuts down the shop on his website on sundays. He also had a divorce and wants to shoot refuges, so :)
- Udik 6y ago> mostly because mainstream Christianity does not currently have many restrictions which inconvenience people day to day. Note however that Islam has similar restrictions but an entirely different way to deal with them (respecting the spirit as well as their letter). My pet theory about the approach of the three main Abrahamic religions to restrictions: 1) Christianity: (loosely) respects the spirit but not the letter; 2) Islam: respects both the spirit and the letter. 3) Judaism: respects only the letter.
- GoblinSlayer 6y agoIt's absolutely well known Islam often copes in the jewish way. "Faith alone" sends the spirit on a vacation too.
- rsynnott 6y agoThere do seem to be cases where Islam is more willing to adapt the rules, though. For instance, most halal meat in Europe at least is now slaughtered with stunning, and this appears to be acceptable to most local Muslim authorities provided that the stunning is done in a way that is unlikely to cause permanent injury (so, no captive bolt guns etc). This is arguably staying within the spirit of the rules (the animal isn't dead when slaughtered, and won't die if you don't slaughter it), but not the letter (in that it's an addition to the prescribed procedure). As far as I know this is _never_ acceptable for kosher slaughter.
- apta 6y ago> This is arguably staying within the spirit of the rules (the animal isn't dead when slaughtered, and won't die if you don't slaughter it), but not the letter (in that it's an addition to the prescribed procedure). It's staying within the spirit and the letter. The letter never dictates NOT to stun the animal. As a matter of fact, there are narrations that order us to make it as easy as possible on the animal being slaughtered. This falls perfectly inline with the sprit and letter.
- shliachtx 6y ago> 3) Judaism: respects only the letter. This demonstrates a woeful ignorance of Judaism, and is a common stereotype promulgated by competing religions