4 ms·
I wonder if there are any studies about the effects of removing highly gifted students from a class of otherwise average students. I'm aware of a few about the
by carlob 6y ago
I wonder if there are any studies about the effects of removing highly gifted students from a class of otherwise average students. I'm aware of a few about the lack socioeconomic mixing: rich kids in classes with just rich kids seem to see almost no positive effect, but poor kids who experience a good social mix in their class fare far better than their peers who are in schools where everybody comes from a poor background.
I would expect a similar effect here: gifted kids who are accelerated might show no long term negative psychological effects, and might do a little better academically, but what about the overall effect on everybody else? Is it really better to have classes with the 1% smartest removed?
At least from a political and ethical perspective I would advocate for greater mixing, teaching more fortunate kids that they should put their advantages to fruit by pulling the rest of the class. In other words focus on collaboration rather than competition. However, I have no data to back this up.
- zozbot234 6y ago> ... what about the overall effect on everybody else? Is it really better to have classes with the 1% smartest removed? This is a function of the method of instruction. "Pulling up the rest of the class" ought to be the teacher's job in the first place but these sorts of "direct instruction" (DI) based workflows, which do help less fortunate kids a lot, have become extremely unpopular. Every teacher wants to be teaching the 1% of gifted kids and have them "learn everything on their own"; no one wants to actually do the hard work of teaching.
- slantaclaus 6y agoThe overall effect on everybody else is that they graduate higher ranked in their class, benefit from grading curves, there may be others. But regardless, saying that we have to sacrifice the smart kid so he/she can benefit the other students....its not the kid's job to do that.