3 ms·
It surprises me that although the Falklands War (and its anti-ship missiles) was last century, people are still eager to build full-size aircraft carriers. (I
by 082349872349872 6y ago
It surprises me that although the Falklands War (and its anti-ship missiles) was last century, people are still eager to build full-size aircraft carriers.
(I will start taking scots' independence noises seriously after someone puts forth a concrete proposal about what to do with HMNB Clyde.)
- pjc50 6y agoWhat's the specific question as to why that means you can't take it seriously? The big problem is the nuclear material, but getting rid of that has long been an undercurrent of independence anyway. I suspect what would most likely be negotiated would be some kind of "treaty port" arrangement for non-nuclear vessels. Scotland would likely not be an Ireland-style neutral. The aircraft carriers are .. very much a "power projection" thing, like Trident, Britain buying itself international hard man status like a knuckle tattoo. On the other hand, there's no proven alternative to carriers for achieving air superiority away from land bases.
- 082349872349872 6y agoNot that I can't take the idea seriously, just that if the english were to identify where they'd move the sub pens, it would be easier to classify as being in the "project" category rather than in the "proposal."
- pjc50 6y agoIt's apparent that England isn't going to plan for it any more than they're going to plan for Brexit. Whether it happens or not is kind of an orthogonal question to that. Although my personal opinion is that Irish reunification is more likely in the next decade, especially if the UK makes an EU-incompatible ag trade deal with the US.