22 ms·
I managed to establish that flask headspace oxygen concentration played a critical role in synthesizing silver nanocubes after spending a year trying to reprodu
by XorNot 6y ago
I managed to establish that flask headspace oxygen concentration played a critical role in synthesizing silver nanocubes after spending a year trying to reproduce a paper which didn't mention it at all.
Emailing the original papers authors I managed to extract the comment "we place the lid lightly on top of the vial" (which only stood out in a photo as something which didn't make sense) and then filmed a bunch of my vials and noted that whether it worked depended on how the water evaporating/condensing sealed against the loose fitting lid.
(This was after a lot effort spent drying ethylene glycol too)
Turns out, you can get a perfect result everytime if you drop the reaction vial headspace oxygen to 17-19%.
People just don't monitor what they should (or take a 1/10 success rate since for most nanoparticulate research one vial goes a long way).
I'm still really proud of that but damn does it explain replication problems to me.