6 ms·
> It was just, I guess, experience and skill. Lab technique is definitely a thing. Mostly it's about knowing what not to pay attention to so that you can give
by bsder 6y ago
> It was just, I guess, experience and skill.
Lab technique is definitely a thing. Mostly it's about knowing what not to pay attention to so that you can give extra attention to the things that matter. It's also about recognizing the intermediate signals that say "Yep, still good." (ie. Are the bubbles the right size? Is the foam the right color? Does it smell right/wrong? Did a layer of glop form at the correct step?)
However, I rarely see anyone taking good enough notes to reproduce an experiment. I had a Physics Lab taught by a professor who would randomly take someone's notebook in an assignment and reproduce the experiment using your notes--and fail you on that assignment if he couldn't.
Very few students ever passed that. You really have to be excessively meticulous. However, when you are debugging a real experiment without a known correct answer, if you aren't that meticulous you will never find your own bugs.
- scott_s 6y agoI'm reminded of baking. The recipes for everything are all known, but there's still an enormous amount of skill and tacit knowledge required.
- asdff 6y agoFinding an old protocol that has been marked up by a former lab member is like finding the Half Blood Prince's potion book.
- amluto 6y agoHah. A lot of excellent bread recipes involve a step like “add flour until it looks right.”
- kwhitefoot 6y agoNot the ones intended for professional use. I have a textbook of cookery [1] written for students intending to become professional cooks, it emphasizes precision measurements and repeatable processes. Where it expects adjustments it explains what it means and what constitutes "it looks right". It stands head and shoulders above pretty much all other cookery books I have read. But of course it lacks glossy pictures and is not backed up by a video of Nigella Lawson in a low cut dress (not that I'm objecting to Nigella and her cleavage) [1] Professional Cookery: The Process Approach by Daniel R. Stevenson
- XorNot 6y agoI managed to establish that flask headspace oxygen concentration played a critical role in synthesizing silver nanocubes after spending a year trying to reproduce a paper which didn't mention it at all. Emailing the original papers authors I managed to extract the comment "we place the lid lightly on top of the vial" (which only stood out in a photo as something which didn't make sense) and then filmed a bunch of my vials and noted that whether it worked depended on how the water evaporating/condensing sealed against the loose fitting lid. (This was after a lot effort spent drying ethylene glycol too) Turns out, you can get a perfect result everytime if you drop the reaction vial headspace oxygen to 17-19%. People just don't monitor what they should (or take a 1/10 success rate since for most nanoparticulate research one vial goes a long way). I'm still really proud of that but damn does it explain replication problems to me.
- StandardFuture 6y agoIs it an actual "reproduction" if the specific experimental steps cannot be reproduced? I think what people do not understand is that there is a difference between "result" and "process". The existence of one is not a validation of the other. As programmers, we know this: there are many ways of implementing the same algorithm. So, it really depends on what is being "reproduced". Is it the outcome? Or is it the process? If it is just the outcome, then the original authors could merely store an example of it as the only proof necessary. But, my intuition says that it is much more often the process that is needing to be reproduced/proven. Therefore, "lab technique" should have nothing to do with a proof of process. Either it can or it cannot be done as it has been defined.
- bsder 6y ago> Either it can or it cannot be done as it has been defined. You can't define everything precisely--and inaccuracy may not lead to failure--just suboptimal results. My favorite example of this was a semiconductor fabrication lab in college. There were 4 or 5 masks which have the step of "Align masks on lithography machine using alignment marks on silicon and expose photresist". Okaaaaay. No big deal, you're putting lines and crosses in the center of other lines and crosses visually through a stereo microscope. Humans do that well. Erm, that lithography machine is possibly older than the professor and likely hasn't been maintained in about the same timeframe. So, the vernier screws have an enormous amount of backlash. If you've used shitty guitar tuners, you know how to deal with this. If you haven't, you spend a lot of time being frustrated figuring out what backlash is and how to deal with it. Okay, that's lab technique. However, if even if you do know about backlash, this wastes time on a piece of equipment which is already time constrained. If you actually know something about semiconductors and think a bit about the process, you realize that Mask 2 is the crucial alignment because it defines your critical dimensions and screwing it up will haunt you while you can be a little more cavalier about the other masks. So, you spend way more time fighting the machine on Mask 2 to get it right (because it's important) and you spend less time on the rest. That's also lab technique. Finally, if you're paranoid, you test the measurement equipment and calibrate it every single time you enter the lab. You note the serial numbers of the broken ones and only use the ones that reliably give correct measurements. Your prize for this level of lab technique is that your transistor gives gorgeous graphs and works exactly like the lab claims it should while everybody else gets mushy results, at best.