4 ms·
I agree it's an "absurd counterexample". That's the whole point of a reductio ad absurdum. It shows the fallacy at the core of the argument with which you whole
by naasking 6y ago
I agree it's an "absurd counterexample". That's the whole point of a reductio ad absurdum. It shows the fallacy at the core of the argument with which you whole heartedly agreed. Precision is important in ethics.
Furthermore, even if I were to be maximally charitable in interpreting the argument as "damaging a person is typically morally more serious than damaging an object, and psychologically damaging a person is typically worse than physically damaging an object", not everyone would even agree with that, contra your post. I don't think you appreciate how broad ethics is as a topic; virtue ethics and deontological ethics both dispute the premises from which this argument is constructed.
Finally, discrediting an argument you agreed with does not somehow discredit or insult you as a person, so not sure where you got that from.
- mdszy 6y agoAssuming that I'm so stupid as to honestly believe that a papercut is equivalent to burning down a store is absolutely an insult to intelligence. You'll find that people are more likely to engage with you when you don't treat them like an absolute idiot.
- naasking 6y agoYou quoted an ethical principle, then said it was obviously true. Now you're claiming that you don't actually believe in the ethical principle that you claimed was so obviously true? If you're now claiming that the principle was "true" in some vague unspecified way, but not literally true, then like I said, say what you mean and mean what you say, and don't get bent out of shape when people point out the problems with this sort of imprecise reasoning.
- mdszy 6y agoIt brings my heart such great joy to know that there are people out there like you who are willing to argue about trivialities that don't actually matter. Not everything is a deep philosophical discussion that needs to get down to absolute true statements. Sometimes it's just someone, like me, who is sick of black people being literally murdered by police and thinks it's absurd that white assholes get more worked up over some property than over black lives. I literally don't give a single shit about absolute ethical principles. I give a shit about black lives. Black lives matter, shut the hell up already.
- Ghjklov 6y agoBlack lives matter? According to black on black crime statistics and black abortion rates, they don't, not even black people themselves. Willing to take the L for saying the truth on this one. It's politically convenient for the left to use the death of a black man (f the police) to rally up support against their opposition as the election comes up, but without that, they will happily ignore the amount of black on black killings that happens in THEIR OWN cities the rest of the year. And then they'll happily support abortion, which is an incredible suppressor of the American black population, making sure they will never grow in numbers enough to make a political difference in this forsaken country on their own and not used as pawns by either political party. I'm sure one day you will be able to convince me that black lives matter and we will finally do something about it to make meaningful change. But it looks like today is not that day. Judging by how the protests and riots have settled down already in less than 2 weeks, they are finished making use of black lives to further their political goals. Just like the time before, and the time before that. When does it end?
- mdszy 6y agoWhat the fuck is wrong with you? If your immediate reaction to statistics (which I am not claiming the accuracy of, by the way, since you provide no sources) is "oh, it's because they're black" then congratulations, you're a racist! Furthermore, the protests have not died down, there have been events that sparked more protests in more places. They're just not being reported as much because "oh well that's old time to move on to the next thing", says the media.
- dang 6y agoPlease stop posting flamewar comments to HN. You've been doing it repeatedly, and we ban that sort of account, because it destroys what the site is supposed to be for. https://news.ycombinator.com/newsguidelines.html https://news.ycombinator.com/newsguidelines.html
- happytoexplain 6y ago>Black lives matter? According to black on black crime statistics and black abortion rates, they don't >Willing to take the L for saying the truth on this one. >Judging by how the protests and riots have settled down already in less than 2 weeks, they are finished making use of black lives to further their political goals. You seem sick with hatred, not to mention casting yourself as a victimized underdog who knows the Truth.