2 ms·
> Why would a practical test be more effective than a discussion about prior work experience? Short coding tests under pressure are extremely unrepresentative o
by kube-system 6y ago
> Why would a practical test be more effective than a discussion about prior work experience? Short coding tests under pressure are extremely unrepresentative of real work and I'm not sure homework-style interviews are much better. I personally don't want to spend an entire weekend on your test and I've dropped opportunities for that reason in the past.
These are good points, and the tests I have given are specifically designed to avoid these issues.
Personally I do this:
* Come up with a simple but realistic 1 or 2 hour task, and write up the request in plain English (do not write a tech spec). It should be task you'd expect anyone to be able to easily do on day one without any assistance.
* Include a short narrative about the end user that clearly implies a specific requirement or two, but don't spell out it out as an explicit requirement.
* Omit a small but important detail that any reasonable person would ask.
* Instruct them to provide a solution to the users problem, and ask questions if something isn't clear.
These are pretty simple to evaluate too:
* Does the code run? (i.e. can the candidate write basic code?)
* Does it meet the user's explicit needs? (i.e. can the candidate follow basic instructions?)
* Does it meet the user's implicit needs? (i.e. does the candidate write code to spec, or do they think about the bigger picture?)
* Did the candidate ask a question about that obvious missing detail? (i.e. does the candidate speak up, or will they make assumptions?)
You would be surprised with how many people don't have the ability to apply their ability to write code to solve simple problems.