3 ms·
Essential workers are not scarce. You need someone to do the job, but there is no shortage of qualified candidates. Hiring and training them is not a huge inves
by nicbou 6y ago
Essential workers are not scarce. You need someone to do the job, but there is no shortage of qualified candidates. Hiring and training them is not a huge investment, and they are somewhat fungible. A department store could replace its entire staff within a week or two with no dip in productivity.
On the other hand, a few disgruntled knowledge workers can send a company into a death spiral if enough of them quit at once.
I guess companies don't care so much about their labourers, because there's an unlimited supply of them. Their skilled workers are perceived as an investment, because they're expensive to replace and shape the direction a company takes.
- pointyfence 6y agoI was having a similar conversation a few days ago. I think that people are conflating how essential a function is with how essential any given person in that function is.
- solarfair 6y agoWhile I mostly agree, I think it’s a stretch to say that an entire workforce could be replaced with no dip in productivity. Unless most of these workers were idle.
- stuaxo 6y agoIt's simply not true that all essential workers do low skilled jobs.
- nicbou 6y agoIt's not. I accidentally implied that, but that wasn't my intention.
- blub 6y agoThat doesn't apply at all to doctors, pharmacists, firemen, police and most essential workers.
- nicbou 6y agoThat's true. I guess I was just thinking about specific people and answered to that.
- TheOtherHobbes 6y agoThis argument was used by any number of consumer electronics outlets, and it was never true. Expert floor staff are not fungible. Only poor floor staff are fungible. It's not even true in department stores. It's simply not true that you can pick someone off the street and train them to sell cosmetics, high-end clothing, or even furniture in a few days. You can train them to do a bad job quickly, but they're not going to find their stride for a good few months.
- hevelvarik 6y agoI dunno, that may once have been true, back when expertise on the show room floor was either par for course or else a competitive differentiator. To me it looks like that the industry made a conscience decision to cost cut expertise from hiring equation. Essentially, the big box guys (who hire most of the employees) are practically self serve. The associates are certainly fungible.
- nicbou 6y agoWhen I was working retail (in consumer electronics), this was not the case. I was replaced quickly and effortlessly. My resignation wasn't the mic drop I thought it would be. They don't need experts. They pay minimum wage. They need people to push extended warranties.
- Shared404 6y ago> A department store could replace its entire staff within a week or two with no dip in productivity. Worked in food service and not retail, but I'm going to call bull on this. If even one of our best left we were screwed for however many weeks it took to find a replacement. That is when they give two weeks, not when they walk out.