5 ms·
If you want a really big competitive advantage, figure out how to hire great people who don't interview well.
by simonw 6y ago
If you want a really big competitive advantage, figure out how to hire great people who don't interview well.
- bluedino 6y agoFind them through word-of-mouth.
- simonw 6y agoYeah that definitely helps a lot. But it means you won't get to hire great people from outside your two-layer deep professional circle (people known by people you know).
- jaaron 6y agoDouble edged sword. Certainly helps to find great talent and build a cohesive team. Also tends to perpetuate our biases, create cliques and echo chambers. Makes it harder for new talent to break in. When I build my teams, I try to balance referrals with newly sourced talent far outside my network.
- nogabebop23 6y agoeveryone also has a pretty shallow pool of quality talent, so it doesn't scale well. Once you've been involved in hiring you see why a company will pass on a likely good candidate to avoid a maybe bad experience. In the longer term it's way less work.
- bluedino 6y agoWorks well for the first 20-100 employees. After that you’re bound to get a solid chunk of bad ones no matter what you do.
- closeparen 6y agoJudgement, taste, sensibility, intuition - this is what human professionals are for. The value of an experienced worker is in the biases he has accumulated.
- jaaron 6y agoDo you really not understand that when I say "bias," I mean prejudices against people that are irrespective of their qualifications for the job? Of course I want to hire people for their technical and professional judgement. That's the whole point of the interview process: to attempt to measure technical knowledge and its application (ie- judgement). It's hard, but we have to try. But if we google "bias in hiring [1]," all the results are around prejudices that have nothing to do with their performance on the job. In this context, bias means discrimination against certain genders, races, religious beliefs, cultural backgrounds and so on. I'll give you the benefit of the doubt: perhaps you are unfamiliar with the generally understood definition of bias when talking about hiring practices. Alternatively, you're selectively and intentionally feigning misunderstanding to advance a position that such prejudice and discrimination is acceptable. [1] https://www.google.com/search?q=bias+in+hiring https://www.google.com/search?q=bias+in+hiring
- dpoochieni 6y agoSo basically you see yourself as so irredeemably biased (racist or sexist?) that the network you keep is also this badly biased?
- scarface74 6y agoMost people hang out with people who are like them.
- blaser-waffle 6y ago"people like them" is relative. Most of my crew are programmers -- but are Chinese, Indian, and German.
- scarface74 6y agoOr you know we could look at statistics instead of anecdotes. https://www.washingtonpost.com/news/wonk/wp/2014/08/25/three-quarters-of-whites-dont-have-any-non-white-friends/ https://www.washingtonpost.com/news/wonk/wp/2014/08/25/three...
- dpoochieni 6y ago> There are a number of factors driving these numbers. Simple population counts are one of them: There are more white people than black people in the United States, so it makes sense that the average American is going to have more white friends than black friends. That's the major factor but I guess if one tries hard enough they can see the angels dancing on the head of a needle. Why would they dismiss it in the 2nd paragraph to come up with some holier-than-thou babble. Of course, and then one could do some math and figure out that in a graph where 75% of nodes are X and 25% are Y and random relationships occur, the average Y will have a higher proportion of X friends than the average X will have of Y friends. ? Where does one jump from this to some kind of moral argument? It's like saying the avg kitesurfers has more non-kitesurfer friends than the avg non-kitesurfer has kitesurfer friends. F*, this grouping and deindividuation of people that the American left has degenerated to, has truly has become a post-modern religion with it's requisite self-flagelation and utopic symbolism.
- deleted 6y ago[deleted]
- edoceo 6y agoI use a gig to hire process for this. It works very well. I've been meaning to write more about it but I also get income for helping with hiring around this model so im a bit conflicted. The whole answer is long and complex. Basically: give candidate a proper task on your project and evaluate them based on that work - the "interview" is less than an hour, the "work" is longer (many hours (and you pay for it)) - provides a solid evaluation across their skill-set
- monksy 6y ago> and you pay for it But just think about all of those business people that want free work and to hire people that are willing to throw themselves in to the project for no extra comp. /s I agree.. also that sets boundaries.
- edoceo 6y agoI filter those jerks out before even letting them see my candidates. Step #1 is for me to work with the company to find the project slice - which they also have to comp my time. So they spend more time and cash on the traditional method...then complain about a lack of talent. Resume keyword filters and non-technical recruiters are a (not) surprising waste.
- fredophile 6y agoThat will work for some people but not everyone. At my current job I can't monetize work I do outside the company without approval. That means I can't go through you application process unless I quit first. Even if I was allowed to do this I don't think I'd want to. The time commitment of an extra project on top of my normal workload is not something I want.
- wolco 6y agoUsually the ones who do terrible in the interview but the resume is solid. That person knows how to do their job but can't sell themselves. When they end up finding work they rely on good work. The opposite is a great interviewer. They will have an even better resume. Rarely are the best workers but can somehow stage what little they do into looking like a top performer. Will likely move on when the going gets tough.
- blaser-waffle 6y agoNot sure why this is downvoted, these are not universally true, but I've definitely seen what the parent describes.
- claudiawerner 6y agoI'm incredibly nervous about job interviews. I'll start sweating in the first two or three minutes even over Zoom. I recently "fell into" a job because my university supervisor recommended me to a friend of his at a small business in which my only test was a code review I could do the day before. But I worry that for any future job because I'm terrible at algorithm questions, and I suspect (and I doubt this is just impostor syndrome) that I'm simply not great at algorithms, despite a small cachet of personal projects, which aren't that impressive either.
- tj0 6y agoI'm five years into my career, and still experience this same kind of anxiety. Only recently did I revisit algorithms as I'm getting serious about my job search now, and am still super nervous. Not to mention, having a family, I don't have a ton of time to study for the gauntlet decent tech companies put in place to vet candidates. As for personal projects? See lack of time above. I'm lucky to get an hour a week to work on something I actually enjoy. Forget about building something unique/useful/worth public launch in any kind of reasonable time. Also, let's not forget the fun non-compete/anything you build while employed with X is owned by X clauses. Hiring in general is broken. In tech it just seems amplified.
- bluGill 6y agoMost jobs are who you know. So cultivate the kind of person who interviews well and will quickly be trusted to say hire you. My first job all open positions went to Jon (last name hid), if he handed a name that person was called in, the interview was reverse, unless you really did something stupid you had the job, the purpose of the interview was to convince you to take it. If Jon didn't know anyone a head hunter was called for a 6 month contract, with option to hire if we liked you. So moral of this story is know Jon. Where I work now we train people on how to put you at ease. It works okay, I think.
- tj0 6y agoThat's definitely something that seems to be reiterated often -- the power of networking is real. You'd think after hearing it since high school (some time ago, not gonna date myself lol) I'd actually spend more time nurturing the network I do have. Luckily my current and last position didn't require any kind of mental gymnastics (my soft skills are great in terms of software engineers), but I'm still wondering what lies behind those gates kept locked by technical trivia and tricky buzzword algorithms that send CVs to the void before a human ever sees them. My current situation is a bit different than previous (trying to transition tech stacks and job titles now) so the nerves are a bit different. The anxieties are just as real as before though, albeit the payoffs are higher with the new goals. Guess you could call em game day jitters. Your interview process sounds improved over traditional corporate style interviews. My last employer had similar tactics (put the interviewee at ease, casual conversation), and it led to the best 18 months I've had in my career yet.
- bryanrasmussen 6y agothat would really only be a big competitive advantage if great people who don't interview well were more numerous than those who interview at least adequately, or if those great people were greater than the great people who do interview adequately. I guess it would still be something of a competitive advantage though if you were a great person who got hired despite interviewing poorly you might be more grateful than those who interview well. But anyway I don't know that anyone has the stats on how many great people interview poorly - I would of course only put myself as average, albeit lucky, and I interview poorly half the time but some times I interview really well, for some reason, and when it clicks like that I get the job. So I assume if there is hope for as bad an interviewee as myself there must be hope for all the other poor interviews out there.
- bradlys 6y ago> that would really only be a big competitive advantage if great people who don't interview well were more numerous than those who interview at least adequately, or if those great people were greater than the great people who do interview adequately. It sounds like you're making it a zero sum game. Isn't it reasonable to assume that you could create an interview process that does well for both parties rather than one that is exclusionary? Isn't the issue with the current interviewing practices is that it is exclusionary and doesn't assess people correctly?
- bryanrasmussen 6y agoI guess, maybe it's possible, but as I have not have not had any eureka moment recently leading me to pursue a method for doing it, and have not read anything where someone had a moment that sounded to me like "hey that might work!" I am prone to cynicism - one of my failings. If every variation of interviewing people try seems to lead to a sub-optimal zero-sum game I worry that interviewing is zero-sum and what one should try to do is to work the optimization angle. but like I said - cynic.
- jmchuster 6y agoDo great people really interview _that_ poorly? It's certainly possible, but it seems almost an edge case that's not worth trying to exploit. Rather, I feel the main competitive advantage would be to become better at interviewing. Learn how to evaluate people on their skills, rather than your own personal belief on how a problem should be solved. Understand how someone is thinking and approaching a problem, instead of a yes/no checkbox. Be able to determine what a candidate's strengths are and how you can best utilize them, rather than how to fit them into a pigeonholed role you have imagined.
- bsder 6y agoIt's simpler. Hire people who don't suck and train them. And, amazingly enough, you find those people generally become quite good.
- AtomicOrbital 6y agoyou want to hire for intelligence and hard working both of which are largely unchangeable ... but yes that is those `who don't suck`
- 908B64B197 6y agoOr who don't interview at all. [0] I've seen great devs intern twice at the same company while in college and spend several years there as full time right after graduating, only jumping ships when a friend at an other company specifically reached out. They are essentially invisible to any recruiters. [0] https://www.joelonsoftware.com/2005/01/27/news-58/ https://www.joelonsoftware.com/2005/01/27/news-58/
- blaser-waffle 6y agoInternships and direct, intra-personal headhunting isn't new, and is absolutely a part of HR & hiring. But those interns were interviewed, no doubt.
- 908B64B197 6y agoYes, but the company hiring them took a chance on them earlier and was willing to invest for at least a year before getting a junior dev. And I find that the interview at intern level can be less strict.