3 ms·
One of the radical freedom bits of open source software licensing is that anyone could use it no matter how heinous their goals are. There are attempts to work
by zdw 6y ago
One of the radical freedom bits of open source software licensing is that anyone could use it no matter how heinous their goals are.
There are attempts to work around this like the JSON license "The Software shall be used for Good, not Evil.": https://json.org/license.html https://json.org/license.html
A commercial company selling licenses, and therefore profiting off "bad things" is a bit less neutral, as this website shows.
But what if an OSS developer accepts a patchset from a "bad guy", what then? That contributed code has value... but we're getting into the whole "how was it created", which could invite comparisons to other scientific results produced in morally questionable ways, like through animal or involuntary human testing.
Ethics is hard.
- baggy_trough 6y agoSince there's no objective universal definition of good and evil, how can you rely on your ability to use code under such a license? It doesn't matter what your project is - if the licensor wants to, they can find some way to describe it as evil. So, in my opinion, those licenses are themselves unethical.