3 ms·
“It isn’t good or bad, it simply is” implies it followed some amoral natural law. These are human-created systems, though, and would be built upon human ethics
by bumby 6y ago
“It isn’t good or bad, it simply is” implies it followed some amoral natural law.
These are human-created systems, though, and would be built upon human ethics and morals. Stating academia as an institution just “is” isn’t much different than asserting the military-industrial-congressional complex just “is”
- luckylion 6y ago> implies it followed some amoral natural law Doesn't it? If you have two lions of the same physical ability and one of them hunts for six hours a day and the other one hunts for 12 hours a day, which one would you expect to be more successful? > Stating academia as an institution just “is” isn’t much different than asserting the military-industrial-congressional complex just “is” It's not about academia specifically though, it's about any and all systems where individuals compete. Given similar talent, the one who puts in more time/effort will likely win.
- bumby 6y agoExcept I don’t think we can/should reduce our institutions to such a simple model. There’s many more inputs than just work-hours. We build our institutions to guard against this. That’s why we don’t live in an anarcho-capitalist society and have things like anti-trust laws.
- luckylion 6y ago> There’s many more inputs than just work-hours. Obviously, but if you consider those to be very similar at the top of some field, wouldn't you expect work-hours to be important in predicting the outcome? I'm sure you can draw clear lines between two individuals, but when you look at many people of similar ability, how much time they put in will most likely predict their results pretty well. > We build our institutions to guard against this. We do? Is there a thing where you can explain that you're as smart as other people and therefore it shouldn't matter that they work 5 days a week in some area and you only work one day, and that it's unfair that they produce more results than you and get the promotion/grant/whatever you compete for? I've never heard of it.
- bumby 6y agoThe anti-trust example in the previous statement is one. It doesn't matter if someone is more successful, even if it's due solely to an extraordinary work ethic; societal institutions will artificially limit their market share. Sports is another example. Leagues put salary caps as well as minimum salaries to artificially limit compensation. Both sports and economics put these in place to provide a bulwark against such "natural laws" in favor of human defined ethics like fairness.
- luckylion 6y agoThose are extremely different things. There is no monopoly in academics or personal career. Sports is a terrible example imho, because most of the compensation isn't in the salary, it's in the ad contracts. > Both sports and economics put these in place to provide a bulwark against such "natural laws" in favor of human defined ethics like fairness. That's not at all why we have anti-trust laws. They are harmful to the economy, that's why. If they weren't, that is, if monopolists usually were more efficient in lowering prices/increasing quality/innovating than companies that had competitors, we'd have no issue with monopolies at all.
- bumby 6y agoFair enough on the anti-trust point. But societal institutions still put artificial limits, such as minimum wages. In different eras, the U.S. put maximum limits as well. The U.S. also limits profits in certain industries through regulated monopolies (e.g., insurance, utilities). It's a strange moving of the goal-posts to posit that sports doesn't count due to endorsements. There are also examples of leagues that limit these as well (UFC being one, although the case can be made this is of the managers interest). It becomes more pronounced in amateur levels (e.g., Olympics). The military is an institution that sometimes put numerous limits on one's professional career regardless of contribution. Someone above brought up E. Weinstein. He's been a vocal critic of how academic institutions use immigration institutions to artificially drive down labor rates. There are seemingly boundless examples of institutions either biasing or leveling outcomes. The larger point being institutions do put artificial limits on all kinds of interactions. These interactions have societal ethics forced upon them and don't exist in a libertarian vacuum consisting of only natural laws.
- devit 6y agoThere's no need for anyone to win, both the person working 6 hours and the one working 12 hours can contribute and be compensated proportionally to their efforts.
- MaxBarraclough 6y agoNo, they can't. There are more grad students than postdoc positions. Modern academia is famous/infamous for this.
- fock 6y agoOne of them will be dead by exhaustion a short time after he piled up his bounty only to have it rot because he doesn't know a freezer...
- specialist 6y agoIMHO, depersonalizing a problem may help to mitigate it. My IRL analogy: Working in election integrity, I emphatically encouraged my peers to pointedly ignore intention, to frame problems as "errors", not "fraud". From the systems view, all fraud are technically errors. And the conversation is full stop over the moment someone says "fraud", "chicanery", "electioneering". But if you can keep the convo in the "safe space" of "errors", avoid partisanship and blame and whatever, then it's easier to build coalitions, persuade others, neutralize opposition. Just my two cents.
- bumby 6y agoI think that’s a good way to phrase it. Another is to focus on the “process” rather than the “person”. An election process can fail to provide validation against errors. A person, however, commits fraud.
- specialist 6y agoYa, process vs people is a smarter dichotomy. More general purpose. Thank you.
- kspacewalk2 6y agoHuman-created systems (science funding in the US) are absolutely built upon human ethics and morals and subject to modification. But the concept of productivity = f(time-invested) is indeed an amoral natural law. f(.) is not necessarily something simple like a line, maybe a sigmoid, I don't know. But the idea that time spent on a problem is, away from corner cases like 0 and 24/7, positively correlated with results and productivity - that idea is indeed amoral and not really mutable. You bring up the military, and I can draw another analogy - development of a military technology. Sure, you can decide nukes are amoral, but the more actors there are in the world, the higher the chance that someone else will develop them anyway, and will wipe the floor with you, amoral as though they may be. So do you really have a choice? Generall,y when a technological advance is possible and brings about significant advantages for the entity that develops it, it will eventually happen. It won't be good or bad, it just will be. Agonize about it or don't, develop it or let yourself be overpowered by the one who will - your moral choice entirely.
- bumby 6y agoI’m with you in the first paragraph. My larger issue is when the function is reduced to a single variable like time invested. There are some cases where time invested can even be counterproductive because of competing effects (think of newbies working out who assume more is always better and eventually become overstrained). My point is that it’s naive to think time = productivity in anything but trivially simple systems. To think that about complex systems can get you in trouble Your second paragraph I’m less sure about. It comes across as realpolitik (that may have been your point) which can be used as a rationalization to continue immoral behavior. My bringing up the military is that we can create systems that incentivize certain behavior (lobbying for a military need) and confuse that with natural law when in reality it can be mitigated through a differently oriented system (in this case, one that more clearly separates money and politics)