3 ms·
The dirty secret of video codecs is that you can't make a modern video codec that isn't patent encumbered, which in turn makes it so that even if they wanted to
by p_l 6y ago
The dirty secret of video codecs is that you can't make a modern video codec that isn't patent encumbered, which in turn makes it so that even if they wanted to be open, they go for defensive patents, which in turn perpetuate the situation.
At least the patent licenses usually used with MPEG mean that private use of open source implementations is free.
- 1_player 6y ago> The dirty secret of video codecs is that you can't make a modern video codec that isn't patent encumbered Why is that?
- mekster 6y agoIt would be hard to build a new algorithm without stepping on other established algorithms that are patented.
- p_l 6y agoPretty much every method involved in high-efficiency video compression has a patent on it, doesn't matter how small part is involved. Now compound this by the fact that a) trying to make an exhaustive patent search to get a verifiable claim that you don't infringe on any patent is very problematic b) known patent pools like MPEG-LA are known not to cover everything. So you can make a reasonable bet that you avoid infringing patents by avoiding patents from MPEG-LA and few other better known groups, but you can't actually guarantee that you're not infringing on any patents. This resolves, sort of, into a game of chicken and depends heavily on whether a lesser known patent holder decides it's worth it to bother executing against you... but even if they don't, unless they come out with a royalty-free license, the possibility of patent is a Damocles' Sword hanging over your codec.
- jariel 6y ago"make an exhaustive patent search to get a verifiable claim that you don't infringe on any patent" Is there even such a thing? Isn't the problem that one has to actually go to court to get the answer to this question?
- dfox 6y agoIn theory you can do such kind of search. Problem is that doing that is impractically expensive (and at least in some jurisdictions doing that can actually raise your liability in case of patent infringement).
- vertex-four 6y agoBecause there are companies with a lot of money in this space which spend all their time trying new things and patenting anything they come up with, even if it doesn't make it into a published codec, basically. The way to get around this is to exist in the EU and avoid providing anything to the US.
- jandrese 6y agoThe field is littered with companies holding submarine patents just waiting for that big payday when something using some tiny part that they patented gets popular and deployed to millions of devices so they can surprise everybody with their pricey licensing terms and huge lawsuit.
- MikusR 6y agoThat's what AV1 is.
- selectodude 6y agohttps://www.streamingmedia.com/Articles/ReadArticle.aspx?ArticleID=139636 https://www.streamingmedia.com/Articles/ReadArticle.aspx?Art... Care to try your luck?
- clouddrover 6y agoI think that's more a case of Sisvel trying their luck. I don't think they'll be successful. The Alliance for Open Media was careful to avoid potential patent problems during AV1 development. So, unless AOMedia seriously failed in that effort, AV1 will be alright.
- p_l 6y agoBeing careful and being successful are two different things, especially given how hard it is to do an exhaustive search over patents to ensure that no, no claim in any patent filing touches your code, especially given that there are regimes where patent filings for software get pretty much a rubber stamp and are based around "first to file" even if there's prior art.
- ihuman 6y agoI'm confused. How is Sisvel able to sell a license for AV1 patents when they're not a member of AOMedia? Do they actually have AV1 patents, or are they trying to trick companies that would rather pay up than risk violating patents?
- inthewings 6y agoThat's what patent trolling is
- vertex-four 6y agoBasically, unlike copyright, you don't even have to know that someone else patented something in order to infringe on a patent and have them come out of the woodwork later. It's just even more expensive if you do know. The patent system was not designed to have every tiny little technique patented, and this is its failure mode.
- cyphar 6y ago> The dirty secret of video codecs is that you can't make a modern video codec that isn't patent encumbered The existence of Theora, VP8, VP9, and now AV1 seems to contradict that theory. You could argue that they infringe on some unknown patents, but that is also arguably true of patent cabals like MPEG (you just hope that the cabal is big enough that there aren't any patentholders lurking outside). The only difference is that with a patent cabal you have the fun of having to obey the restrictions of everyone who showed up with a possibly-related-in-some-way patent and joined the cabal. Not to mention that it isn't necessary for a patent pool to be a cabal. AOMedia has a similar structure to a patent cabal except it doesn't act like a cabal (its patent pool is royalty-free in the style of the W3C). So even if the argument is that a patent pool is a good idea (and video codecs cannot be developed without them), there isn't a justification behind turning the patent pool into a cabal. > At least the patent licenses usually used with MPEG mean that private use of open source implementations is free. You say that, but there's a reason why some distributions (openSUSE for one) still can't ship x264 (even though the code itself is free software). Not to mention the need for Cisco's OpenH264 in Firefox (which you cannot recompile or modify otherwise you lose the patent rights to use it). The existence of the MPEG patent cabal isn't a good thing, and any minor concessions you get from them do not justify their actions.
- mtgx 6y ago> but that is also arguably true of patent cabals like MPEG (you just hope that the cabal is big enough that there aren't any patentholders lurking outside) Apparently, they aren't. There are at least 2 other patent pools that claim patents for HEVC, and I think I saw 3 in some other article before: https://streaminglearningcenter.com/codecs/hevc-ip-mess-worse-think.html https://streaminglearningcenter.com/codecs/hevc-ip-mess-wors...
- p_l 6y agoAs others mentioned, VP8, VP9 and AV1 all are patent encumbered - they just happen to have licenses that are royalty-free and as someone mentioned, include retaliation clauses which help fighting off submarine patents - but that's essentially a possibly high-stakes game of chicken.
- auscompgeek 6y agoAre AV1 and VP9 not modern video codecs? Or are you suggesting the patent claims have substance?
- p_l 6y agoThey are modern video codecs which are playing chicken with possible submarine patents. Ultimately, it's a question of how much you're gonna risk to get where you want, and how much power/influence/wealth you can bring to squash a possible lawsuit.
- pavon 6y agoBut H.265 and H.266 have the same risk - worse actually, as multiple submarine patents claims have risen again H.265, and there are now multiple licensing organizations that all claim they need to be paid if you want to use H.265, and over a decade later their claims still haven't been legally settled. To completely avoid risk your only choice is to to use old technology where all the patents have expired (20 years in US), like MPEG-2. The next lowest risk is to use H.264 and VP9 which have been out for a while and whose the patent pools have stabilized over the years (and the original parts of the standard will have their patents expire soon - but not some of the newer profiles). After that I would argue that AV1 is less risky that H.265 and H.266, as a lot of work was put into intentionally avoiding patented technology that was not part of the pool, and no one outside the pool has yet made patent claims against it.
- ksec 6y ago>To completely avoid risk your only choice is to to use old technology where all the patents have expired EVC baseline is basically that, only using technology based on H.264 that are already expired or soon to be expired and patented techniques from companies that are giving it away to the standard. In some way EVC is even more exciting than VVC.
- muizelaar 6y agoThere are patents that cover AV1 and VP9 they just are just licensed without royalties: https://aomedia.googlesource.com/aom/+/refs/heads/master/PATENTS https://aomedia.googlesource.com/aom/+/refs/heads/master/PAT...
- speedgoose 6y agoSoftware patents aren't a thing in ~~Europe~~ a few European countries. Sure it's difficult to ignore the American market for a company, but an independent developer could specify a state of the art video codec without thinking about patents. Edited because I didn't know that some European countries accept software patents.
- p_l 6y agoSoftware patents are a very complex thing. For example, many countries in EU do not allow patents on software, but that's not something you can claim to be true for all of them - at least before Brexit, since iirc UK was pretty happy to provide software patents. Then there's a case where if you're really willing you can, as far as I understand, force a patent dispute through WTO, with possibility of patent valid in USA being executed for example in Poland, despite the fact that the patent is invalid in Poland (it doesn't matter if your software is part of physical solution in Poland, algorithms of any kind are not patentable).
- speedgoose 6y agoOne more benefit of the brexit for mainland Europe! I didn't know about using the WTO to dispute invalide patents. I guess a WTO dispute can make sense for a Boeing software patent used by Airbus. I wonder whether the WTO would care about an independent developer. It's not very good press, but perhaps it's fine for them.
- p_l 6y agoWTO doesn't care, WTO serves as a forum to get it through. The question is, does a "practicing entity" holding the patent cares enough to go through the hardest route to get the patent executed using WTO as a forum? One needs to compare costs and benefits. It's why patent trolling involved pretty much few counties in Texas, because that's where the costs were lowest compared to benefits.
- makomk 6y agoIt's not just the UK that allows software patents in practice - as the discussion hints at, Germany does too, and if I remember rightly pretty much the last patent affecting MP3 was a German patent on zero-padding held by Philips, who enforced it aggressively against manufacturers of devices like music players.
- nullc 6y ago> The dirty secret of video codecs is that you can't You can, but fraunhofer certainly isn't trying! > At least the patent licenses usually used with MPEG mean that private use of open source implementations is free. 0_o that is not at all the truth.