5 ms·
If one trusted numbers like this, and followed a chain of en vogue codecs back through history, you'd expect that a modern codec would produce files sizes like
by ajross 6y ago
If one trusted numbers like this, and followed a chain of en vogue codecs back through history, you'd expect that a modern codec would produce files sizes like 3% of MPEG-2 on the same input data. It's all spin.
I'm sure it does better, but I'm equally sure it'll turn out to be an incremental benefit in practice.
> I wonder how many more CPU instructions are required per second of decoded video compared to HEVC.
CPU cycles are cheap. The real cost is the addition of yet another ?!@$!!#@ video codec block on every consumer SoC shipped over the coming decade.
Opinionated bile: video encoding is a Solved Problem in the modern world, no matter how much the experts want it to be exciting. The low hanging fruit has been picked, and we should just pick something and move on. JPEG-2000 and WebP failed too, but at least there it was only some extra forgotten software. Continuing to bang on the video problem is wasting an absolutely obscene amount of silicon.
- syshum 6y agoThe video codec battle is not about file size, it is about streaming bandwidth.
- yjftsjthsd-h 6y agoAre those different? If I chop up a video file into chunks, I'm streaming it, and if I save a stream I have a file. With a buffer, I would expect the sizes involved to be identical. (Although without a buffer I'd expect streaming to be worse)
- gsich 6y ago>Are those different? No. In the end you transmitted a file that has a certain size. It doesn't really matter if you save that file or just use a volatile buffer.
- Sebb767 6y agoYes. For the most part, you need to be able to encode to a low and constant bandwidth at 30/60/+ fps, possibly even with limited latency. Then there are also some lesser, but also important aspects, such as the need to be able to start in the middle of a stream, handle lost packages etc.
- occamrazor 6y agoLatency will become more important with video conferencing (already now) and AR/VR.
- gibolt 6y agoVideo sizes are not shrinking. 8K is coming, with even bigger sizes on the way. That matters at scale. As long as someone sees the benefit, people will keep pursuing it. Compression (as like all tech) is a moving target with the platforms regularly improving on many axes.
- deleted 6y ago[deleted]
- sp332 6y agoMPEG-2 doesn't support video larger than 1920x1152, so it's hard to compare on 4k video, let alone 8k. But according to https://www.researchgate.net/publication/321412719_Subjective_and_objective_quality_assessment_of_MPEG-2_H264_and_H265_videos https://www.researchgate.net/publication/321412719_Subjectiv... H.265 can achieve similar visual quality with 10% of the bit rate of MPEG-2 even on SD video (832*480). [Edit: not 720p]
- entropicdrifter 6y ago832x480 is ~480p video (720x480 is standard widescreen dvd) 720p is 1280x720
- deleted 6y ago[deleted]