9 ms·
Oh, spare us. Playing at Mr. Citation Needed is not a form of smartness and is in fact a pernicious sort of bias. If you are too afraid of being wrong, you'll
by SamReidHughes 16y ago
Oh, spare us. Playing at Mr. Citation Needed is not a form of smartness and is in fact a pernicious sort of bias. If you are too afraid of being wrong, you'll miss out on the benefits of being right.
- bjelkeman-again 16y agoOn the other hand there is a lot of gunk out there which everyone "knows to be right" which in fact isn't. Quite often a scientific test with documented results is not a bad thing to have.
- kmfrk 16y agoThe problem is that the "advice" might do more harm than good, even though good was intended. Skin care is a prime example of this; people recommend what works for them, but these products will, de facto, not work for some. This is something that goes against a lot of HN's start-up philosophy, so it might meet some more disagreement. A lot of the advice dispensed on HN are maxims - take them or leave them - and the same thing applies.
- heyitsnick 16y agoI'm not playing Mr. Citation. If you re-read my comment I explicitly say that there is some great information here. When people simply give advice based on their history - things like "use your money to live closer to work" is good advice. You don't need a citation for this; it's just someone's advice and it's good advice. "Perhaps you haven't considered the great benefits from using your money to cut down your commute time; you may reflect how negative the daily commute is" is an excellent suggestion. However the specific advice I quoted, e.g. "Buy a more expensive bed", "eat 'good' food", is useless, potentially harmful advice without citation. Already there are responses to my parent comment about how they found an in-expensive bed is actually preferrable. It would be infinitely more useful if someone actually discussed recent research in to different beds as advice. Anecdotal recommendations in this area are useless and ironically they propagate the same folklore of 'common wisdom' that this quora question specifically mentioned in the title: "advice... against common sense or wisdom".
- marknutter 16y agoNo, actually she/he makes a really good point. How much wisdom do we accept at face value? How much of it is actually true?