4 ms·
Plenty of people have pointed out that changes to society create problems and even leave us worse off in terms of happiness or health or freedom etc. I'd recomm
by LatteLazy 6y ago
Plenty of people have pointed out that changes to society create problems and even leave us worse off in terms of happiness or health or freedom etc. I'd recommend Jared Diamond on agriculture for a shorter, better written, non homicidal alternative:
https://www.discovermagazine.com/planet-earth/the-worst-mistake-in-the-history-of-the-human-race https://www.discovermagazine.com/planet-earth/the-worst-mist...
But here is thing: you don't get to decide. You're whole society doesn't get to decide. You have to do what guarantees your survival, not your happiness/freedom/comfort/honour etc.
If you reject technology or agriculture or weapons, you may well be happier for a while. Then you're technological/agricultural/militaristic neighbours will come over and wipe you out.
American Indians were famously happier, healthier, freer people than European settlers. Now they're mostly gone. It's not nice, but it's reality.
- Synaesthesia 6y agoIt’s up to us to make the society we want to. The US need fear no other country, it’s probably the most secure nation in history right now. So they could be free to conduct any social experiment.
- LatteLazy 6y agoIf the social experiment is to throw away all the guns, close the military, dismantle the economy and all go live in the forest, how will the US STILL be the most powerful nation?
- Synaesthesia 6y agoWell that’s quite the hypothetical. Why would they do that? I think even with a tiny army it will enjoy security. That’s what it had prior to WW2. But the US still controls about 50 percent of the global corporate wealth. That’s an enormous amount of control. It’s got full control of both oceans which surround it, it’s not really vulnerable to any land based attack either.
- LatteLazy 6y ago>Why would they do that? That is what the manifesto calls for. That is the inevitable result of abandoning technology and going back to villages of 50 people.
- oldsklgdfth 6y agoI have had this thought many times. Unfortunately the necessity argument is what keeps defense research and spending high in the US and around the world. Because at the end of the day if we don't invent [next gen technology], some other country will and they will use it for evil.
- leto_ii 6y ago> But here is thing: you don't get to decide. You're whole society doesn't get to decide. This is why we have established what is sometimes called a 'rule-based international order', so that we can have a world where might makes right doesn't apply anymore. Where the weak get protection and the strong are compelled to act morally and legally. Unfortunately, of course, the rules mostly stay on paper and the world continues to be driven by power and violence. This however doesn't mean that we shouldn't push for a better world and that we shouldn't hold people and nations responsible for their brutality.
- LatteLazy 6y agoThis is the core issue: how do you get everyone, every single person on earth, all 7bn to agree not to be dicks, not to want more than a bare subsistence lifestyle, not to engage in violence or coercion and not to invent tech? If we could solve human nature, we could have any ideological system. Communism would work, or anarcho capitalism or whatever. But we can't. We can't get people to cut back enough to avoid a global warming catastropy.
- leto_ii 6y ago> how do you get everyone, every single person on earth, all 7bn to agree not to be dicks Unfortunately, as you can imagine, I don't have an answer. I'm actually quite afraid that there's no answer and that we as a species aren't capable of large scale rational and compassionate cooperation. The global warming catastrophe won't wait for us. I'm quite afraid that my life won't end nicely. I don't expect to have a long and peaceful retirement.
- zozbot234 6y ago> we as a species aren't capable of large scale rational and compassionate cooperation. Most likely true, as far as it goes. Ironically enough, the closest thing we get to 'large-scale (even world-scale) rational and compassionate cooperation' is the very "industrial society" mentioned in the OP. You may not like industrial and post-industrial society, but it's not clear that there's any alternative if you want "everyone" to be involved.
- Miner49er 6y agoI think this is a good point. You're basically saying the strongest and most violent always wins out, not necessarily the best idea. Maybe that's part of the reason Kaczynski turned to violence.