3 ms·
I think employer based healthcare works fine in more corporatist countries. Here in Germany we have a multi-payer system that includes the option for employer-b
by Barrin92 6y ago
I think employer based healthcare works fine in more corporatist countries. Here in Germany we have a multi-payer system that includes the option for employer-based plans, but it's embedded in a culture that isn't going to throw you on the street in a pandemic, and there is of course the rest of the public healthcare system to catch people. In federal states purely national systems are hard to realise.
The US has the same issue I think, not to mention that the federal government doesn't always seem to be in good shape. Maybe better to go deeper than just healthcare and ponder whether the liberal capitalism needs to taken down a notch in favour of putting other stakeholders first instead of centralising healthcare further.
- robert_foss 6y agoJust like the US system, the German one has a lot of inefficiencies. How many people are employed in the health insurance sector? It is a _large_ industry, and someone has to pay their salaries. How much paperwork do have to deal with regarding health insurance? Having lived in Canada and Sweden, both which have a single payer system, I can tell you that the life improvement is very real. That being said, I can only assume the German system is less broken than the US one. People with no jobs do have access to health insurance here.
- nicbou 6y agoThat's incorrect. German health insurance is not tied to your employer. Losing your job has no impact on your coverage, and your employer has no say on how you are insured. If you are curious about how German health insurance works, I wrote a long, detailed, thoroughly verified guide about it for expats. It's a good intro to the system. https://allaboutberlin.com/guides/german-health-insurance https://allaboutberlin.com/guides/german-health-insurance
- Barrin92 6y agoI am German and you're not correct. There are several types of public insurance. If you've chosen to be a member of a Betriebskrankenkasse or Innungskrankenkasse, your insurance status is tied to your job, because that insurance is provided by your employer. Should you lose your job you are entitled to a month or so of additional coverage called nachgehender leistungsanspruch and you can obtain public health insurance through a non jon-related public insurer. That's why the German system is universal (you're never going to be uninsured), but the option for employer-based insurance exists and is quite popular.
- nicbou 6y agoFair point. This is a blind spot in my research, and I will amend the article when I find the time. They at least deserve a mention. There are no notable differences: same price, same coverage, and no particular gotchas. That being said, I can't think of a scenario where you'd want to keep a specific job for health insurance reasons. In that sense, your health insurance is not tied to your job. If you were with a BKK, you'd fall back into the public system, which should provide equivalent coverage.